Class 9 . English . Kaveri . Twin Melodies

Chapter 11: Twin Melodies

Ch 11

English

Class 9

Lecture 1

Twin Melodies – Act-I

Reference video · Lecture 1Twin Melodies – Act-I

Act I

Act I

  • Setting: The scene takes place in Iqbal’s room, with a small rack, a wooden table stacked with books and posters of famous flute players.
  • Rehearsal: Shruti plays violin with Iqbal (flute), Avinash (tabla) and Peter (keyboard) in an Indo-Western fusion group.
  • News: Iqbal reads a newspaper review praising Shruti’s violin performance with her father, Nabin Sharma.
  • Conflict: Shruti is anxious because she has not told her strict father that she rehearses fusion music or plans to perform at a concert.
  • Reason for worry: Her father believes Hindustani classical music, especially ragas and aalaaps, is the only music worthy of an artist; Shruti fears he will see violin fusion with Western tunes as disrespectful.
  • Resolution: Her friends encourage her to speak honestly. Shruti decides to tell her father at dinner that night.
The children’s ensemble combines the violin, flute, tabla and keyboard.
The children’s ensemble combines the violin, flute, tabla and keyboard.

Shruti Sharma

  • An aspiring violinist who performs both with her father and with a fusion group.
  • Respectful of her father’s views, but keen to explore a different style of music.
  • Anxious about telling him the truth, yet resolves to do so after her friends encourage her.

Guru Nabin Sharma

  • Shruti’s father, a violinist and Principal of Sangeetika Music School.
  • Strict about musical choices and firmly committed to Hindustani classical music.

Iqbal, Avinash and Peter

  • Shruti’s supportive friends and members of her fusion group: Iqbal plays flute, Avinash plays tabla and Peter plays keyboard.
  • They advise her to talk to her father instead of letting her fear grow.
Theme

Music, choice and honest communication

The scene shows the tension between respecting family beliefs and pursuing one’s own musical interests. Open communication and encouragement help Shruti face a difficult conversation.

Word meanings
Crescendo
A gradual increase in the loudness of music.
Desecration
Disrespect towards something considered sacred.
Ragas and aalaaps
Elements of Hindustani classical music.
Bite the bullet
Face a difficult or unpleasant situation courageously.
Come around
Eventually agree or change one’s opinion.
Bring it up
Introduce a subject into conversation.
Lost in one’s thoughts
So absorbed in thinking that one is unaware of what is happening.
Throw a party
Organise a celebration.

Why is Shruti worried about telling her father about the concert?

Answer: She knows he is strict about music and believes Hindustani classical music is the only worthwhile style. She fears he may consider her fusion performance disrespectful to the violin and his beliefs.

How do Shruti’s friends help her, and what does she decide to do?

Answer: They reassure her that speaking to her father is better than hiding the truth. Shruti decides to tell him about the fusion music and concert at dinner that night.

Quick recap

  • Shruti rehearses Indo-Western fusion with Iqbal, Avinash and Peter.
  • A newspaper review praises Shruti’s performance with her father.
  • Shruti has kept her rehearsals and concert plans from her strict father.
  • Nabin Sharma believes Hindustani classical music is the only music worthy of an artist.
  • Her friends encourage honest conversation, and Shruti resolves to speak to him at dinner.
Lecture 2

Twin Melodies – Act-II

Reference video · Lecture 2Twin Melodies – Act-II

Act II

  • Shruti is absent-minded at dinner because she is worried about telling her father, Nabin, that she wants to participate in an Indo-Western fusion concert.
  • Nabin refuses permission. He believes performers should appear only once every six months and fears group music will drown Shruti’s individual style.
  • He strongly disapproves of fusion music and mocks Shruti’s request that he attend a rehearsal before deciding.
  • Leela scolds Shruti for not asking permission earlier. Shruti admits her mistake, promises not to hide things again, and is told to go to bed.

Shruti

  • Timid but determined to ask permission to perform in the concert.
  • Recognises that hiding the plan was wrong and promises to be more honest.

Nabin

  • Strict and firm about his rule of one performance every six months.
  • Protective of Shruti’s individual musical style, but dismissive of fusion music and unwilling to consider her request.

Leela

  • Warm and teasing at first, but scolds Shruti for keeping the concert plan from her father.
  • Urges Shruti to be honest and reminds her it is time to sleep.
Theme

Tradition and change

The disagreement over fusion music shows a clash between Nabin’s traditional musical beliefs and Shruti’s interest in contemporary forms.

Theme

Communication and understanding

Shruti’s secrecy adds to the family tension. Honest conversation and a willingness to listen could help the family understand one another.

Word meanings
Contempt
A strong feeling of dislike and disrespect.
Hubbub
Loud, confused noise.
Iterated
Repeated or said again.

Will Nabin go to the rehearsal? Give a reason.

Answer: Probably not. He rejects Shruti’s request that he attend the rehearsal and mocks the idea of practising fusion music before leaving.

Can Shruti and her parents understand one another?

Answer: Yes, if they communicate honestly and listen to each other. Shruti has promised not to hide things, and Nabin could try to understand her interest before dismissing it.

Quick recap

  • Shruti is worried about asking Nabin for permission to participate in an Indo-Western fusion concert.
  • Nabin refuses, citing his performance rule and his concern for Shruti’s individual style.
  • He disapproves of fusion music and mocks her request that he attend a rehearsal before deciding.
  • Leela scolds Shruti for not asking permission earlier.
  • Shruti admits her mistake and promises not to hide things again.
  • The scene highlights a clash between traditional and contemporary musical preferences.
Lecture 3

Twin Melodies – Act-III

Reference video · Lecture 3Twin Melodies – Act-III

The performance changes Nabin’s mind

Act III

  • Shruti plans to practise with Avinash and Peter one last time before telling them she cannot join their performance.
  • Her parents watch the group play and enjoy the music. Nabin praises the performance, especially Shruti’s careful handling of the raga.
  • Nabin offers the children the music room so they can practise regularly. Shruti then speaks privately with her parents.
  • Leela explains that Nabin once defied his family’s wishes to play the violin. His family belonged to a traditional school of vocal music, and the violin had not yet been incorporated into classical Indian music.
  • Because of this, Nabin’s father saw his choice of the violin as a betrayal of family values and tradition. Nabin worked hard and eventually succeeded as a violinist.
  • Nabin admits he had underestimated Indian music and feared losing Shruti. Remembering his own experience, he trusts her and promises to support her group at the concert.

Shruti

  • Takes her art seriously and is committed to performing with the fusion group.
  • Speaks openly with her parents and appreciates their support.

Nabin

  • Initially fears that Shruti’s musical choices may distance her from her family’s traditions.
  • Reconsiders after recalling that he also challenged tradition to pursue the violin, which was not yet part of classical Indian music.
  • Praises Shruti and agrees to support her group.

Leela

  • Helps Nabin understand Shruti’s choice by reminding him of his own past.
  • Supports Shruti’s musical aspirations.
Theme

Tradition and personal choice

Artistic choices can honour musical heritage while making room for new forms. Understanding one another’s experiences helps families accept change.

Word meanings
Painstakingly
With great care and effort.
Worked his fingers to the bone
Worked extremely hard.
Root for
Show support for.

Quick recap

  • Shruti’s parents are impressed by the group’s performance.
  • Nabin praises Shruti’s musicianship and offers the group a place to practise.
  • Leela recalls that Nabin went against family expectations to play the violin.
  • The violin had not yet been incorporated into classical Indian music, so Nabin’s father viewed his choice as a betrayal of tradition.
  • Nabin recognises that his fears were unfounded and supports Shruti’s choice.
  • The act ends with greater understanding between Shruti and her parents.

English — ALL CHAPTERS

1

How I Taught My Grandmother to Read

View

2

Bharat Our Land

View

3

The Pot Maker

View

4

Gifts of Grace: Honouring Our Vocations

View

5

Winds of Change

View

6

Canvas of Soil

View

7

Vitamin-M

View

8

I Cannot Remember My Mother

View

9

The World of Limitless Possibilities

View

10

Nine Gold Medals

View

11

Twin Melodies

View

12

A Friend Found in Music

View

13

Carrier of Words

View

14

Word

View

15

Follow That Dream

View

16

Believe in Yourself

View