Class 11 PCM . English . Hornbill . The Ailing Planet the Green Movement S Role
Chapter 4: The Ailing Planet: The Green Movement’s Role
Ch 4
English
Class 11 PCM
The Ailing Earth.
The Green Movement and a New Worldview
A shift in human thinking
- Context: Nani Palkhivala’s article was published in *The Indian Express* on 24 November 1994.
- Green Movement: It rapidly captured worldwide attention; the world’s first nationwide Green Party was founded in New Zealand in 1972.
- New worldview: Humanity is moving from seeing Earth as a machine to seeing it as a living, interconnected system with needs and vital processes.
- Responsibility: Humans must act as Earth’s stewards and trustees, protecting the planet for future generations.
Sustainable development — Development that meets present needs without reducing future generations’ ability to meet their own needs.
Human impact on Earth
- Popularised: The World Commission on Environment and Development popularised the concept of sustainable development in 1987.
- Lusaka zoo image: A mirror inside the cage labelled “The world’s most dangerous animal” makes humans confront their destructive impact.
- Partnership: The author argues that people must replace domination of nature with a cooperative relationship.
- Species: About 1.4 million living species had been catalogued; estimates suggested that 3–100 million more remained unnamed.
Biological Systems and Environmental Decline
The systems that support life
- Four systems: Fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands provide food and most industrial raw materials, apart from minerals and petroleum-based synthetics.
- Overuse: When human demands exceed these systems’ sustainable capacity, productivity falls.
- Consequences: Overfishing can collapse fisheries; deforestation removes forests; grasslands become barren; and croplands deteriorate.
- Species loss: Tropical forests are centres of evolution; their destruction places many species at risk of extinction.
Forest loss and its effects
- Causes and effects: Overfishing and cutting forests for firewood damage ecosystems; burning dung also removes natural fertiliser from the soil.
- Warning: The saying “Forests precede mankind; deserts follow” links forest destruction with the spread of deserts.
- Global scale: The article reports tropical forest loss of 40–50 million acres annually and cites an estimate of forest loss approaching 1.5 acres per second.
- Fuelwood: The World Bank estimated that forest planting needed to increase fivefold to meet the fuelwood demand expected in 2000.
Environmental Protection in India
Law and forest depletion
- Article 48A: The Constitution directs the State to protect and improve the environment and safeguard the country’s forests and wildlife.
- Enforcement gap: Palkhivala laments that laws are often not respected or enforced, allowing serious social and environmental problems to continue.
- Forest loss: The article cites a reported Indian forest loss of 3.7 million acres a year; the actual loss was estimated at about eight times the official rate.
- Wider warning: A UN study using satellites and aerial photography found environmental conditions critical in many of the 88 countries examined.
Population and Poverty
Population growth and its effects
- Growth timeline: World population reached one billion around 1800; a second billion was added by 1900, and the twentieth century added another 3.7 billion.
- Rapid increase: The article estimates world population at 5.7 billion and says it grows by one million every four days.
- Development and fertility: Fertility tends to fall as incomes, education and health improve; therefore, the author calls development the best contraceptive.
- Poverty cycle: Poor families may have more children, but population growth does not guarantee more workers; it can increase unemployment and perpetuate poverty.
- Proposed response: Palkhivala rejects compulsory sterilisation and argues for voluntary family planning, warning that population pressure can deepen hunger and hardship.
- India: The article estimates India’s population at 920 million—more than the combined populations of Africa and South America—and urges population control to receive top priority.
The Era of Responsibility
Shared responsibility for the planet
- Transcending concern: The central concern is now the survival of both humanity and the planet.
- Industry’s role: Businesses must make environmental performance part of their responsibility and continued success.
- Life-tenancy image: Margaret Thatcher’s comparison presents people as tenants who must maintain Earth, not owners with permanent rights.
- Future generations: Lester Brown’s image of borrowing Earth from our children stresses our duty to pass it on in good condition.
Human responsibility for Earth
The essay presents Earth as an interconnected living system and argues that human survival depends on respecting its limits and protecting it for future generations.
Sustainable development
Environmental protection, responsible use of resources, development and voluntary family planning are linked to a safer future and the reduction of poverty.
- Holistic and ecological view
- Seeing the world as an interconnected whole, with humans as part of nature.
- Languish
- Remain neglected or in a poor condition.
- Ignominious darkness
- A state of obscurity or anonymity.
- Inter alia
- Among other things.
- Decimated
- Severely reduced or destroyed.
- Catastrophic depletion
- A disastrous reduction in amount or supply.
- Transcending concern
- A concern that rises beyond narrower interests; here, the survival of the planet and its people.
- Gripped the imagination
- Captured widespread interest and attention.
- Dawned upon
- Became understood or newly realised.
- Ushered in
- Introduced or brought about.
- Passport for the future
- A means of securing a hopeful future.
- Passed into current coin
- Became widely used in everyday language.
Why does the author describe Earth as an ailing planet?
What does the zoo notice, “The world’s most dangerous animal”, signify?
How does population growth threaten the future of human society?
Quick recap
- The Green Movement encouraged a holistic view of Earth as a living, interconnected system.
- Sustainable development meets present needs without compromising the needs of future generations.
- Overuse damages fisheries, forests, grasslands and croplands, undermining ecological and economic security.
- The essay highlights India’s forest loss and the gap between environmental laws and their enforcement.
- Population growth rose from one billion around 1800 to 5.7 billion at the time of writing; India’s 920 million exceeded the combined populations of Africa and South America.
- People, governments and industries share responsibility for protecting Earth for future generations.
Childhood (Poem)
Poet and central idea
- Poet: Markus Natten.
- Central idea: The speaker wonders when childhood ended and connects its loss with growing awareness and independent thought.
Childhood
- The speaker wonders whether childhood ended on the day they ceased to be eleven—that is, when they turned twelve.
- Realising that Heaven and Hell are not geographical places may mark a shift away from childish belief.
- The speaker notices that adults do not always live by the values they talk about.
- Seeing this gap between words and actions may be another sign of growing up.
- The speaker realises that the mind belongs to the individual and can be used freely.
- Forming original thoughts, rather than simply adopting others’ ideas, signals maturity.
- The speaker cannot identify exactly where childhood has gone.
- It seems to survive in the face of an infant, linking childhood with the very young.
| Device | Example | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Refrain | “When did my childhood go?” | Repeats the speaker’s central question throughout the poem. |
| Rhetorical question | “Was that the day!” | Expresses uncertainty and invites reflection rather than a direct answer. |
| Contrast | “they talked of love and preached of love, / but did not act so lovingly” | Highlights the difference between adults’ words and actions. |
| Metaphor | “hidden in an infant’s face” | Presents childhood as something that has moved out of the speaker and remains with infants. |
Growing up and losing childhood
The poem explores childhood as a stage that fades with growing awareness: the speaker questions accepted beliefs, recognises adults’ contradictions and begins to think independently.
Quick recap
- The speaker repeatedly wonders when childhood ended.
- Questioning the geographical existence of Heaven and Hell suggests a shift from childish belief.
- Noticing adults’ contradictions marks a more mature understanding.
- Independent thought becomes a sign of growing up.
- The poem leaves the exact moment of childhood’s loss uncertain.
Exercise
Which stanzas deal with individuality, rationalism and hypocrisy?
What does the poem suggest is involved in growing up?
What is the poet’s feeling towards childhood, and which lines might be considered most poetic?
Quick recap
- Stanza 1 presents rational questioning of religious ideas.
- Stanza 2 exposes the gap between adults’ words and actions.
- Stanza 3 celebrates independent thought and individuality.
- Growing up involves questioning, recognising hypocrisy and losing innocence.
- The poet looks back on childhood with wistfulness and curiosity.
- A reader may choose poetic lines personally, but should explain the imagery or effect.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Portrait of a Lady
2
“We’ re Not Afraid To Die...If We Can All Be Together”
3
Discovering Tut: The Saga Continues
4
The Ailing Planet: The Green Movement’s Role
5
The Adventure
6
Silk Road
7
Note-making
8
Summarising
9
Sub-titling
10
Essay-writing
11
Letter-writing
12
Creative Writing
1
The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse
2
The Address
3
Mother’s Day
4
Birth
5
The Tale of Melon City