Class 11 PCM . English . Snapshots . The Tale of Melon City

Chapter 5: The Tale of Melon City

Ch 5

English

Class 11 PCM

Lecture 1

The Unusual Tale of a Melon King

Reference video · Lecture 1The Unusual Tale of a Melon King

Vikram Seth

  • Vikram Seth is the poet of “The Tale of Melon City.”
  • The poem is introduced with the attribution “(After Idries Shah).”
  • It appeared in Mappings (1981) and was later included in Collected Poems.

The Tale of Melon City

1In the city of which I sing
2There was a just and placid King.
3The King proclaimed an arch should be
4Constructed, that triumphally
5Would span the major thoroughfare
6To edify spectators there.
7The workmen went and built the thing.
8They did so since he was the King.
9The King rode down the thoroughfare
10To edify spectators there.
  • A calm, supposedly just king orders a grand arch built across the main road.
  • He rides beneath it to impress the people and display his authority.
11Under the arch he lost his crown.
12The arch was built too low. A frown
13Appeared upon his placid face.
14The King said, ‘This is a disgrace.
15The chief of builders will be hanged.’
16The rope and gallows were arranged.
17The chief of builders was led out.
18He passed the King. He gave a shout,
19‘O King, it was the workmen’s fault’
20‘Oh!’ said the King, and called a halt
21To the proceedings. Being just
22(And placider now) he said, ‘I must
23Have all the workmen hanged instead.’
24The workmen looked surprised, and said,
25‘O King, you do not realise
26The bricks were made of the wrong size.’
  • The low arch knocks off the king’s crown, so he orders the chief builder executed.
  • Blame shifts from the builder to the workmen, then to the wrongly sized bricks.
27‘Summon the masons!’ said the King.
28The masons stood there quivering.
29‘It was the architect...’, they said,
30The architect was summoned.
31‘Well, architect,’ said His Majesty.
32‘I do ordain that you shall be
33Hanged.’ Said the architect, ‘O King,
34You have forgotten one small thing.
35You made certain amendments to
36The plans when I showed them to you.
  • The masons blame the architect, who is then ordered to be hanged.
  • The architect points out that the king himself changed the plans.
37The King heard this. The King saw red.
38In fact he nearly lost his head;
39But being a just and placid King
40He said, ‘This is a tricky thing.
41I need some counsel. Bring to me
42The wisest man in this country.’
  • The king is furious when he realises he may be responsible.
  • To preserve his image of justice, he asks for advice from the wisest person.
43The wisest man was found and brought,
44Nay, carried, to the Royal Court.
45He could not walk and could not see,
46So old (and therefore wise) was he —
47But in a quavering¹ voice he said,
48‘The culprit must be punished.
49Truly, the arch it was that banged
50The crown off, and it must be hanged’.
  • The extremely old and frail adviser declares that the arch caused the crown to fall.
  • His absurd verdict is that the arch itself must be punished.
51To the scaffold² the arch was led
52When suddenly a Councillor said —
53‘How can we hang so shamefully
54What touched your head, Your Majesty?’
55‘True,’ mused the King. By now the crowd,
56Restless, was muttering aloud.
57The King perceived their mood and trembled
58And said to all who were assembled —
59‘Let us postpone consideration
60Of finer points like guilt. The nation
61Wants a hanging. Hanged must be
62Someone, and that immediately.’
  • A councillor objects that hanging the arch would dishonour what touched the king’s head.
  • Fearing the restless crowd, the king decides that someone must be executed immediately, regardless of guilt.
63The noose was set up somewhat high.
64Each man was measured by and by.
65But only one man was so tall
66He fitted. One man. That was all.
67He was the King. His Majesty
68Was therefore hanged by Royal Decree.
  • The noose is too high for everyone except the king.
  • The king is executed under his own decree, exposing the absurdity of the process.
69‘Thank Goodness we found someone,’ said
70The Ministers, ‘for if instead
71We had not, the unruly town
72Might well have turned against the Crown.’
73‘Long live the King!’ the Ministers said.
74‘Long live the King! The King is dead.’
  • The ministers are relieved that someone was executed because they feared a revolt.
  • Their contradictory cry of loyalty while the king is dead adds to the poem’s irony.
75They pondered the dilemma; then,
76Being practical-minded men,
77Sent out the heralds to proclaim
78(In His [former] Majesty’s name):
79‘The next to pass the City Gate
80Will choose the ruler of our state,
81As is our custom. This will be
82Enforced with due ceremony.’
  • The ministers decide that the next person through the city gate will choose the new ruler.
  • They follow custom with formal ceremony instead of questioning whether the method is sensible.
83A man passed by the City Gate.
84An idiot. The guards cried, ‘Wait!
85Who is to be the King? Decide!’
86‘A melon,’ the idiot replied.
87This was his standard answer to
88All questions. (He liked melons.) ‘You
89Are now our King,’ the Ministers said,
90Crowning a melon. Then they led
91(Carried) the Melon to the throne
92And reverently set it down.
  • An idiot, whose usual answer is “a melon,” is asked to name the king and gives that answer.
  • The ministers crown a melon and carry it to the throne, obeying the custom literally.
93This happened years and years ago.
94When now you ask the people, ‘So —
95Your King appears to be a melon.
96How did this happen?’, they say, ‘Well, on
97Account of customary choice.
98If His Majesty rejoice
99In being a melon, that’s OK
100With us, for who are we to say
101What he should be as long as he
102Leaves us in Peace and Liberty?’
103The principles of laissez faire
104Seem to be well-established there.
  • The people accept the melon king because it leaves them in peace and liberty.
  • The ending satirises passive acceptance and a political system that values non-interference over effective rule.
Word meanings
quavering
Trembling; wavering, especially in the voice.
scaffold
A platform used for the execution of criminals.
DeviceExampleEffect
SatireThe king’s shifting blame and the ministers’ convenient decisionsMocks rulers and officials who care more about appearances and order than justice.
IronyThe “just and placid” king is executed under his own decree.Highlights the gap between the king’s claimed fairness and the absurd outcome.
Rhyme“King” / “thing”; “high” / “by”The regular rhyming couplets create a light, story-like tone that contrasts with the events.
Repetition“Long live the King!”Makes the ministers’ loyalty sound hollow when the king is already dead.
Theme

Power, Justice and Public Choice

The poem ridicules arbitrary justice, scapegoating and rule by custom. The people tolerate an absurd ruler as long as he leaves them in peace and liberty, suggesting that freedom from interference can matter more to them than capable leadership.

Quick recap

  • The king orders an arch built, but it is too low and knocks off his crown.
  • Blame passes from the chief builder to workmen, masons, the architect and finally the arch.
  • To satisfy the crowd, the king demands an immediate execution without a proper search for guilt.
  • The king is the only person tall enough to fit the noose and is executed by his own decree.
  • Custom makes the next passer-by choose the ruler; an idiot names a melon, which is crowned.
  • The people accept the melon king because he leaves them in peace and liberty.
Lecture 2

Exercise

Reference video · Lecture 2Exercise

Retell the main events of the poem.

Answer: A King ordered an arch to be built over the main road. When he rode beneath it, the arch knocked off his crown. He demanded that someone be punished, but blame passed from the builders to others. The King ordered a hanging, and the noose fitted only him, so he was executed. Later, the first person to pass through the city gate named a melon as the new ruler. The ministers crowned it, and the people accepted it.

What impression does the poem create of the King and his state? How can peace and liberty be maintained in a state?

Answer: The King seems calm and well-meaning, but his justice is foolish and arbitrary. The state follows procedures without sound judgement: blame is shifted, and a chance choice determines the ruler. Peace and liberty can be maintained through fair laws, impartial justice, protection of citizens’ rights, and accountable leadership. People should be free to express themselves and resolve disagreements peacefully, while respecting others’ rights. The poem’s citizens mainly value an undisturbed life and freedom from interference.

Which instances highlight humour and irony in the poem?

Answer: The absurd chain of blame, the King’s execution under his own order, and a melon being crowned create humour. The central irony is that a ruler who claims to uphold justice becomes its victim, while a melon is accepted as king. These events satirise blind obedience and government without reason.

Quick recap

  • The King’s order leads to an absurd search for someone to blame.
  • The chain of blame ends with the King being hanged.
  • A chance answer results in a melon becoming ruler.
  • The citizens accept the melon because they value peace and freedom from interference.
  • Fair laws, impartial justice, protected rights, and accountable leaders help maintain peace and liberty.
  • Humour and irony expose foolish justice, blind obedience, and arbitrary government.

English — ALL CHAPTERS

1

The Portrait of a Lady

View

2

“We’ re Not Afraid To Die...If We Can All Be Together”

View

3

Discovering Tut: The Saga Continues

View

4

The Ailing Planet: The Green Movement’s Role

View

5

The Adventure

View

6

Silk Road

View

7

Note-making

View

8

Summarising

View

9

Sub-titling 

View

10

Essay-writing

View

11

Letter-writing

View

12

Creative Writing

View

1

The Summer of the Beautiful White Horse

View

2

The Address

View

3

Mother’s Day

View

4

Birth

View

5

The Tale of Melon City

View