Gandhi and Shukla: A Tale of Courage and Conviction
Louis Fischer
- Born in Philadelphia in 1896; died in 1970.
- Served as a volunteer in the British Army from 1918 to 1920.
- Worked as a journalist for publications including The New York Times and The Saturday Review; also taught at Princeton University.
- The excerpt is from The Life of Mahatma Gandhi, widely praised as a major book on Gandhi.
Shukla Brings Gandhi to Champaran
A persistent appeal
- At the Indian National Congress convention in Lucknow in December 1916, poor Champaran sharecropper Rajkumar Shukla asked Gandhi to visit his district.
- Shukla was illiterate but resolute: he followed Gandhi to different places and waited at his ashram until Gandhi agreed to meet him in Calcutta on a fixed date.
- Gandhi and Shukla travelled by train to Patna. The servants at Rajendra Prasad’s house mistook Gandhi for another peasant and would not let him draw water from the well.
- Gandhi went to Muzaffarpur first to learn more about the peasants’ conditions. He arrived at midnight on 15 April 1917; Professor J. B. Kripalani and students welcomed him, and Professor Malkani gave him shelter despite the risks of helping a supporter of home rule.
The Indigo Sharecroppers’ Grievance
The exploitative arrangement
- Large estates in Champaran belonged to English landlords and were worked by Indian tenants. Their chief commercial crop was indigo.
- Under long-term contracts, tenants had to grow indigo on three-twentieths of their land () and surrender the entire crop as rent.
- After Germany developed synthetic indigo, landlords persuaded sharecroppers to pay compensation to leave the indigo arrangement.
- When peasants learned about synthetic indigo, they wanted the compensation returned. Some hired lawyers; landlords used thugs against those who resisted.
- Gandhi criticised lawyers for charging large fees and argued that court cases could not truly help peasants who were crushed by fear. Their first need was freedom from fear.
Civil Disobedience in Champaran
Gandhi challenges the authorities
- In Champaran, Gandhi sought information from the landlords’ association and the Tirhut commissioner. The commissioner tried to intimidate him and ordered him to leave, but Gandhi stayed.
- At Motihari, Gandhi continued investigating peasant grievances. When he received news of a maltreated peasant, he set out to visit the village but was ordered back and served with a notice to quit Champaran.
- Gandhi signed for the notice and stated that he would disobey it. Summoned to court, he admitted breaking the order but described a conflict of duties: obeying the law versus serving humanity and the nation according to conscience.
- He refused bail and asked the court to impose its penalty. The judge released him and postponed judgment; the case was later dropped on the Lieutenant-Governor’s order.
- Thousands of peasants gathered outside the courthouse. Their spontaneous support showed that British authority could be challenged and began their release from fear.
- Gandhi asked local lawyers what they would do if he were jailed. They decided that returning home would abandon the peasants, and agreed to follow him into prison if necessary.
Investigation and the official inquiry
- Gandhi and the lawyers recorded statements from about 10,000 peasants, collected documents and gathered other evidence against the landlords.
- In June, Gandhi met Lieutenant-Governor Sir Edward Gait after four prolonged interviews. Gait appointed an official inquiry commission comprising landlords and government officials, with Gandhi as the peasants’ sole representative.
- Gandhi had expected a short visit, but spent an uninterrupted seven months in Champaran and returned for further visits.
Settlement and Wider Reform
The refund and its impact
- Faced with strong evidence, the planters agreed in principle to refund money taken from the sharecroppers. Gandhi asked for 50 per cent; when the planters offered 25 per cent, he accepted.
- The amount mattered less than the planters being made to surrender money and prestige. Peasants learned that they had rights, defenders and the courage to resist injustice.
- Within a few years, British planters left their estates, which returned to the peasants; indigo sharecropping disappeared.
Education, health and sanitation
- Gandhi also addressed village poverty and social conditions. Volunteers, including Mahadev Desai, Narhari Parikh, their wives and Gandhi’s family, helped open primary schools in six villages.
- Kasturbai taught personal cleanliness and community sanitation. A volunteer doctor served for six months; the available medicines were castor oil, quinine and sulphur ointment.
- Gandhi noticed the poor living conditions of women. One woman explained that she owned only the sari she was wearing and had no cupboard or box for clothes.
- He continued to supervise the ashram from a distance, sending instructions and asking for accounts, including reminders about maintaining its latrines.
Self-Reliance and Gandhi’s Method
A turning point
- Champaran became a turning point: Gandhi asserted that the British could not order him about in his own country.
- The campaign began not as abstract political defiance but as practical service to poor peasants. Gandhi connected politics with people’s everyday needs.
- He aimed to help Indians stand independently, seeing peasant welfare, self-reliance and national independence as linked.
Andrews and self-reliance
- Gandhi’s lawyer friends wanted the English pacifist Charles Freer Andrews to stay and help them. Gandhi refused, warning them not to depend on an English supporter.
- He believed that a just cause should be won through the Indians’ own courage and effort. Rajendra Prasad later recognised this as a lesson in self-reliance.
Rajkumar Shukla
- Persistent: Followed Gandhi across places and waited until he secured a date for the visit.
- Resolute: Despite being poor and illiterate, he continued to demand help for Champaran’s sharecroppers.
Mahatma Gandhi
- Courageous and principled: Disobeyed the order to leave Champaran while accepting responsibility before the court.
- Practical and compassionate: Combined the struggle for peasant rights with work on education, health and sanitation.
- Strategic and non-violent: Gathered evidence, organised public support and confronted authority without violence.
- Committed to self-reliance: Rejected dependence on Andrews and encouraged Indians to act for themselves.
Courage and freedom from fear
Gandhi’s resistance and the peasants’ courthouse gathering challenged the authority they had long feared. Their courage helped them recognise their rights.
Satyagraha and self-reliance
Gandhi combined truth, conscience and non-violent civil disobedience with practical service. He taught people to rely on their own strength rather than outside support.
- Urge the departure
- Press for the British to leave India.
- Conflict of duties
- A clash between obeying the order and serving the people according to conscience.
- Harbour a man like me
- Give shelter to someone viewed by the authorities as a political opponent.
- Seek a prop
- Depend on another person for support instead of relying on oneself.
Why is Rajkumar Shukla described as resolute?
Why did Gandhi accept a refund of only 25 per cent?
How did the Champaran episode demonstrate Gandhi’s method of satyagraha?
Quick recap
- Shukla’s persistence brought Gandhi to the Champaran sharecroppers’ cause.
- Gandhi arrived in Muzaffarpur at midnight on 15 April 1917.
- Tenants had to grow indigo on of their land and surrender the crop as rent.
- Gandhi’s refusal to leave Champaran and the peasants’ support challenged colonial authority.
- A mass inquiry led to a 25 per cent refund and restored peasants’ confidence in their rights.
- Gandhi paired political resistance with education, health and sanitation work.
- The episode linked self-reliance, peasant welfare and Indian independence.
Exercise
Champaran and the Freedom Movement
Discussion focus
- Champaran: Consider why Gandhi regarded the episode as a turning point in his life.
- Lawyers: Discuss how Gandhi influenced them, using instances from the chapter.
- Local attitudes: Consider how people in smaller localities viewed advocates of Home Rule.
- Public participation: Identify evidence that ordinary people contributed to the freedom movement.
- Freedom and leadership: Discuss freedom from fear, its importance for the poor after Independence, and qualities of a good leader.
Legal Vocabulary
Vocabulary task
- Deposition: The text gives this as an example of a word related to legal procedures.
- Word collection: Find other legal-procedure words in the text, then add further examples you already know.
Direct Speech and Commas
Language focus
- Direct speech: Identify instances in the chapter and consider why the author includes quotations in the narration.
- Introductory clause: Use a comma after an opening dependent clause: “When I first visited Gandhi in 1942 at his ashram in Sevagram, he told me what happened in Champaran.”
- Following clause: No comma is used before a dependent clause that follows the main clause: “He had not proceeded far when the police superintendent’s messenger overtook him.”
- Opening time clause: Place a comma after an introductory clause: “When the court reconvened, the judge said he would not deliver the judgment for several days.”
Investigating a Public Controversy
Build a balanced case study
- Choose a controversial issue that has affected poor communities, such as the Bhopal Gas Tragedy or the Narmada Dam Project.
- Find out the facts of the case.
- Present your arguments about the issue.
- Suggest a possible settlement.
Quick recap
- The discussion topics cover Champaran, Gandhi’s influence on lawyers, local attitudes, and ordinary people’s participation.
- The discussion also considers freedom from fear and the qualities of a good leader.
- Deposition is given as an example of legal-procedure vocabulary; students find other examples in and beyond the text.
- The language task asks students to identify direct speech and consider the author’s use of quotations.
- An introductory dependent clause is followed by a comma; a dependent clause after the main clause is not preceded by one in the given examples.
- A case study moves from choosing an issue to finding facts, presenting arguments, and proposing a settlement.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood