Class 12 PCB . English . Kaleidoscope . Tomorrow

Chapter 4: Tomorrow

Ch 4

English

Class 12 PCB

Lecture 1

“Captain Hagberd’s Arrival In Colebrook”

Reference video · Lecture 1“Captain Hagberd’s Arrival In Colebrook”

Joseph Conrad

  • Joseph Conrad (1857–1924) was born to Polish parents in Russian Ukraine and began a seafaring life in 1874.
  • He learned English at 21 and became a British citizen in 1886.
  • Major works include *The Nigger of the Narcissus* (1898), *Lord Jim* (1900) and *Nostromo* (1904).
  • He creates atmosphere through careful detail and uses stories within stories to explore inner life and the shifting mind; all his characters suffer from a sense of isolation.

Setting and characters

Hagberd and the Carvils

  • Captain Hagberd was an outsider in Colebrook, and his arrival and reasons for settling there seemed morbid and unreasonable to the townspeople.
  • He bought a plot of ground and had two cheap cottages built; he lived in one and rented the other to blind, retired boat-builder Josiah Carvil, known as a domestic tyrant.
  • A low fence divided the cottages’ back gardens. Josiah’s daughter Bessie hung washing over it, and Hagberd mildly warned that it would rot the wood.
  • Hagberd suggested that Bessie use a clothes-line, but she usually stayed silent or shook her head. His sailcloth clothes, long untrimmed white beard and wild garden made him look eccentric.

Captain Hagberd

  • Eccentric in appearance and habits: he wears stiff sailcloth and leaves his garden overgrown.
  • Hopeful but fixated: despite years without reliable news, he waits for his missing son to return.
  • Mild in manner with Bessie, repeatedly advising her about the washing and fence.

Bessie Carvil

  • Josiah Carvil’s tall daughter, quiet and observant.
  • She listens silently to Hagberd’s advice and shakes her head when he suggests using a clothes-line.

The missing son and the town’s opinion

Why Hagberd came to Colebrook

  • After his wife’s death, Hagberd came to Colebrook following a letter about a sailor with a name like his missing son Harry’s, reportedly seen near a young woman.
  • The letter may have been a hoax. Hagberd searched the area but found no dependable trace of Harry.
  • He believed Harry had once been in Colebrook and would return there, so he sold his home in Colchester, settled in the town and waited.

The barber’s account

  • The barber mocked Hagberd’s changing predictions about Harry’s return, from “next week” to “next month” and later dates.
  • Although reports described a grown sailor, Hagberd pictured a clever, high-spirited boy of about fourteen and could not clearly describe his son.
  • According to the barber, Hagberd’s search began with excitement, became a slow and fruitless effort, and ended in waiting; the barber made this fixation a local joke.
Theme

Hope, isolation and delusion

Hagberd’s hope of reunion gives direction to his life, but his refusal to accept uncertainty isolates him and makes him an object of ridicule.

What brought Captain Hagberd to Colebrook?

Answer: A letter reported a sailor with a name like his missing son Harry’s near Colebrook. Hagberd searched for him, then settled there because he believed Harry would return to the town.

Why did the people of Colebrook have an unfavourable opinion of Hagberd?

Answer: He was an outsider who had settled in Colebrook under circumstances the townspeople regarded as morbid and unreasonable. They also considered his prolonged waiting for Harry eccentric, and the barber mocked his unfounded expectations and confused account of his son.

Quick recap

  • Joseph Conrad (1857–1924) wrote *Lord Jim* (1900) and *Nostromo* (1904); all his characters suffer from isolation.
  • Hagberd bought a plot of ground in Colebrook and had two cottages built there.
  • A letter about a sailor who might be Harry brought Hagberd to the area; he found no reliable evidence of his son.
  • Hagberd settled in Colebrook because he believed Harry would return there.
  • The townspeople viewed Hagberd as an outsider with morbid, unreasonable reasons for settling, and the barber ridiculed his hopes.
Lecture 2

“ The Barber, The Town And The Mad Captain”

Reference video · Lecture 2“ The Barber, The Town And The Mad Captain”

The Barber and Captain Hagberd

  • The barber’s view: He considers Hagberd’s belief in Harry’s return a craze that can be cured by gently teasing him.
  • A change in appearance: Hagberd suddenly appears in a homemade canvas suit and answers questions about it evasively: “For the present.”
  • The town’s response: His unusual appearance first causes a stir, but people eventually grow used to him and disregard him.
  • Daily life: Hagberd remains physically capable but becomes more diffident. He is regarded as a miser and avoids discussion of his clothes.
  • The private hope: Only Bessie knows that he still expects Harry—not next week or next year, but “tomorrow.”

Hagberd and Bessie

  • Growing closeness: Hagberd speaks to Bessie warmly and confidently. She first thinks him mad, then harmless, and gradually feels affection for him.
  • Harry’s imagined future: Hagberd says Harry will be thirty-one the following July and should marry a sensible girl who appreciates a good home.
  • Marriage hint: His winks and his talk of a home, flowers and a drying-line suggest that he imagines Bessie having a place in Harry’s future.
  • Bessie’s response: She blushes at the implication but doubts whether Harry exists or will ever return.

Hagberd’s Life at Sea

  • A coastal sailor: Hagberd spent his sea life sailing close to land and rarely went far from England.
  • Dislike of the sea: He felt deeply attached to life on land and believed sailors endured an exhausting existence, cut off from home.
  • Leaving the sea: After his wife inherited a house and money, he gave up command of an East-coast collier. His longest voyage lasted a fortnight, mostly spent sheltering at anchor.
  • His boast: He claimed never to have been more than eighty fathoms from land.

Everything Prepared for Tomorrow

  • The garden: Hagberd turns over the soil but will not plant until Harry returns. He keeps flower seeds ready and expects Harry to let Bessie choose what to grow.
  • The cottage: He fills the other cottage with furniture, imagining Harry will return and settle there.
  • Bessie’s mixed feelings: She is touched by Hagberd’s kindness and sometimes pretends to believe him, though she doubts Harry’s existence or return.
  • Hope postponed: Hagberd delays every change until tomorrow, making his hope both touching and uncertain.

Captain Hagberd

  • Hopeful and deluded: He is convinced Harry will return tomorrow, though the townspeople have gradually come to disregard him.
  • Practical in detail: He prepares a home, furniture and garden for his son but continually delays using them.
  • Gentle and paternal: He treats Bessie affectionately and imagines her sharing in the family’s future.
  • Marked by hardship: His deep dislike of the sea reflects his longing for a stable home and domestic life.

Miss Bessie Carvil

  • Kind and patient: She listens to Hagberd and sometimes pretends to believe him to calm his excitement.
  • Compassionate but doubtful: She pities his hope while questioning whether Harry exists or will return.
  • Emotionally affected: Hagberd’s affectionate attention and hints about Harry’s future make her blush.
Theme

Hope and Isolation

Hagberd’s expectation of Harry’s return gives his life purpose, while the town’s growing disregard leaves him increasingly apart from its everyday life.

Theme

Longing for Home

Hagberd’s dislike of the sea and his preparations for Harry reveal his desire for the security, warmth and stability of home.

What sort of seaman had Captain Hagberd been?

Answer: He was a coastal sailor who stayed close to land. His longest voyage lasted a fortnight, mostly spent sheltering at anchor, and he claimed never to have been more than eighty fathoms from land.

What did Captain Hagberd hint at that made Bessie blush?

Answer: He hinted that Bessie might become part of Harry’s future: he spoke of Harry marrying a sensible girl and suggested she would have a say in the home and garden.

Quick recap

  • The barber thinks Hagberd’s belief can be cured by gentle teasing; the town gradually grows used to him and disregards him.
  • Hagberd’s hope has narrowed to the belief that Harry will return tomorrow.
  • Hagberd the sailor stayed near England and longed for the security of home.
  • Bessie listens kindly but doubts Harry’s existence or return; Hagberd hints that she may share in Harry’s future.
  • The cottage and garden embody Hagberd’s hope and his repeated postponement of life until tomorrow.
Lecture 3

Caption Hagderd’s Delusion

Reference video · Lecture 3Caption Hagderd’s Delusion

Hagberd’s Delusion and Bessie’s Response

  • Hagberd’s belief: He is convinced that his son will return, arguing that the sea cannot drown him and that he is bound to come back because he is not a sailor.
  • Bessie’s response: When she once questioned this hope, Hagberd reacted with such horror that she feared for his sanity. She never challenged him again.
  • Bessie’s role: She listens patiently and humours him. Hagberd trusts her, considers her sensible, and imagines her as a suitable wife for his son.

Bessie’s Home Life

  • Sacrifice: Bessie spent ten of the best years of her life nursing her father; home life has brought her little comfort.
  • Daily burden: She quietly attends to her blind father, Carvil, who shouts for her and treats her harshly.
  • Appearance and manner: Bessie has a full figure and a tired, unrefreshed face. She remains patient and composed despite her difficult responsibilities.

Carvil and the Walks

  • Mr Carvil: A widowed boat-builder, he became blind while his business was thriving. He has enough money for comfort but behaves as if Bessie were responsible for his blindness.
  • Behaviour: He abuses and commands Bessie, yet depends on her to attend to him and guide him.
  • Walks: Bessie slowly leads Carvil to the sea-wall. Their slow progress is familiar to the townspeople, while Hagberd watches them from near his cottages.

Bessie

  • Patient and considerate: She listens to Hagberd and avoids challenging his fragile hope.
  • Self-sacrificing: She devoted many years to caring for her father.
  • Quietly resilient: She attends to Carvil without haste, despite his shouting and abuse.

Mr Carvil

  • Blind and dependent: He relies on Bessie for care and guidance.
  • Bitter and abusive: He directs his anger at Bessie as if she were responsible for his blindness.
  • Comfortably provided for: His boat-building career had earned him enough money to live well.
Theme

Delusion and Compassion

Hagberd’s fixed hope of his son’s return makes Bessie cautious and compassionate. She stays silent because contradicting him once caused such distress.

How did Bessie react to Captain Hagberd’s ravings?

Answer: She listened patiently and humoured him. After questioning his hope once and seeing how deeply it upset him, she stopped challenging it.

What sort of person was Mr Carvil?

Answer: He was a blind, widowed boat-builder who was bitter and abusive towards Bessie, yet depended on her for care and guidance.

Quick recap

  • Captain Hagberd is convinced that his son will return, and once says, “Tomorrow.”
  • Bessie avoids challenging Hagberd after seeing how deeply doubt upsets him.
  • Hagberd trusts Bessie and regards her as sensible and dependable.
  • Bessie has spent many years caring for her demanding, blind father.
  • Mr Carvil is harsh towards Bessie but relies on her to guide and care for him.
  • Bessie’s patience and self-sacrifice contrast with the men’s dependence on her.
Lecture 4

“Captain Hagberd’s Hope And Bessie’s Frustration”

Reference video · Lecture 4“Captain Hagberd’s Hope And Bessie’s Frustration”

Captain Hagberd’s advertisements and delusion

Captain Hagberd’s advertisements and delusion

  • Hope for Harry: Captain Hagberd keeps advertising for his missing son, although he believes Harry is nearby and will return “tomorrow.”
  • Contradiction: Bessie points out that advertising is unnecessary if Harry is so close. Hagberd’s replies reveal a confused but firm belief.
  • His wife’s death: He blames his late wife’s impatience for her not living to see Harry return; he praises Bessie for being patient.
  • Delusion: He no longer offers rewards because he believes he has already done all that is needed. Bessie supports his hope to soothe him.

Bessie and Captain Hagberd

Bessie and Captain Hagberd

  • Tantrums: Any doubt or lack of attention to his plans for a home with Harry and Harry’s wife makes Hagberd angry. He stamps about, then watches for Bessie to encourage him again.
  • The cottage: He describes the household goods he has collected but keeps the cottage closed to everyone, saving Harry the privilege of seeing it first.
  • Bessie’s response: Despite her tiring life, Bessie sometimes laughs and reassures Hagberd that she is not impatient.
  • A promise for tomorrow: Hagberd imagines Harry will marry Bessie and provide her with a servant. Bessie privately doubts that Harry would even want to see her.

Hagberd’s isolation and Bessie’s burden

Hagberd’s isolation and Bessie’s burden

  • At the railings: Hagberd and Bessie have spoken for years but always from opposite sides of a fence. She pays his rent there each Monday.
  • Outside the cottage: Hagberd is anxious and mistrustful in town; he is especially distressed by comments about his unusual clothing.
  • Winter hardship: Rain soaks his sailcloth suit, while frost and the muddy garden make him worry about what Harry will think.
  • Bessie’s exhaustion: Her demanding father often calls her indoors, limiting her time with Hagberd. She looks weary and cannot imagine her life changing.
  • Old Carvil: Blind Carvil has made himself more helpless than his condition requires and depends on Bessie for even small tasks, keeping her constantly at his service.

Captain Hagberd

  • Deluded: He is certain Harry will return soon, despite years of waiting.
  • Obsessive: He guards the prepared home for Harry and refuses to let anyone inspect it.
  • Dependent on Bessie: Her sympathy and encouragement soothe him, but doubts trigger angry outbursts.

Bessie

  • Patient and compassionate: She listens to Hagberd and sometimes reassures him despite recognising his delusion.
  • Exhausted: Her work and her father’s constant demands leave her pale, weary, and without hope of change.
  • Frustrated: Hagberd’s baseless marriage promises and Carvil’s selfish dependence add to her burden.

Old Mr Carvil

  • Blind and dependent: His blindness is real, but he also refuses to do tasks he could manage.
  • Selfish and controlling: By making Bessie attend to him constantly, he keeps her tied to his needs.
Theme

Hope and delusion

Hagberd’s belief in Harry’s return gives him purpose, but his certainty separates him from reality and makes Bessie’s own hopelessness more painful.

Theme

Bessie’s confinement

Bessie is burdened by both men: Hagberd’s fanciful expectations and Carvil’s deliberate dependence leave her little freedom or hope.

What is the main similarity between Captain Hagberd and old Mr Carvil?

Answer: Both are blind in different ways: Carvil is physically blind, while Hagberd’s delusion blinds him to reality. Their behaviour also burdens Bessie.

Why does Bessie sometimes feel irritated and frustrated?

Answer: She is exhausted by her work and by Carvil’s constant demands. Hagberd’s unrealistic hopes and predictions about her marrying Harry make her own lack of hope more painful.

Quick recap

  • Hagberd’s certainty: He believes Harry will return soon and keeps preparing a home for him.
  • Bessie’s kindness: She humours Hagberd’s delusion, though she doubts his predictions.
  • Hagberd’s isolation: He keeps his cottage and its contents reserved for Harry.
  • Carvil’s dependence: He uses his blindness and laziness to keep Bessie constantly at his service.
  • Bessie’s frustration: Her exhausting duties and the two old men’s behaviour leave her weary and hopeless.
Lecture 5

The Stranger And Hagderd

Reference video · Lecture 5The Stranger And Hagderd

The stranger meets Captain Hagberd

  • A stranger approaches Captain Hagberd, recognises him from his advertisements and asks about his son.
  • The Captain says Harry is coming home tomorrow. When the stranger questions this and jokes about his appearance, Hagberd feels mocked and becomes distressed.
  • The stranger offers information about Harry, but the Captain refuses to let him in, insisting that he already knows enough.

The stranger reveals who he is

  • Bessie comes outside. The stranger learns that the old man has long been troubled by his missing son.
  • The stranger is Harry Hagberd, returned unexpectedly. He thinks someone is deceiving his father by promising that a different man will arrive tomorrow.
  • Harry is amused by the supposed deception and says he will confront the impostor. Bessie struggles to explain the truth.

Bessie explains the Captain’s belief

  • Bessie tells Harry that he himself is the son his father expects tomorrow. Harry is confused because he has returned a day early and had not written ahead.
  • Bessie’s reason: she never contradicted the Captain because the truth might make him miserable or drive him further out of his mind.
  • Bessie also admits that she had partly believed the hope herself; Harry’s actual return seems to make the long-awaited “tomorrow” real.

Harry tries to enter

  • Harry hesitates about staying, saying he dislikes the quiet, confined place. He recalls that on an earlier visit his father tried to stop him leaving.
  • At Bessie’s suggestion, Harry knocks and calls out that he is home. Captain Hagberd warns him not to trust the “grinning” stranger.
  • The reunion fails: the Captain closes the window and throws a shovel at Harry, who says it grazed his shoulder.

Captain Hagberd

  • Hopeful but deluded: he has spent years believing Harry will return “tomorrow.”
  • Sensitive and fearful: he interprets laughter and questions as mockery.
  • Confused and defensive: he rejects his real son because he believes the stranger is an impostor.

Bessie Carvil

  • Compassionate: she avoids contradicting Hagberd because she fears the truth would worsen his suffering.
  • Patient and involved: she has partly shared his hope and tries to help Harry approach him.
  • Anxious: she finds it difficult to explain the situation and trembles during the conversation.

Harry Hagberd

  • Blunt and self-assured: he speaks freely and initially treats the situation as a trick against his father.
  • Restless: he dislikes the stillness of the place and wants activity or space.
  • Good-humoured but wary: he laughs with Bessie, yet remembers his father’s past attempt to stop him leaving.
Theme

Hope, delusion and failed recognition

The Captain’s long-held hope shapes how he sees reality: even when Harry returns, he cannot recognise him. Bessie’s kindness sustains the hope, but also allows the misunderstanding to continue.

Who is the stranger, and how does Captain Hagberd react to him?

Answer: The stranger is Harry Hagberd, the Captain’s son. The Captain mistakes him for a mocking intruder, refuses to let him in and later throws a shovel at him.

What did Harry think the Captain meant by saying his son would come home “tomorrow”?

Answer: Harry thought a stranger was deceiving his father with a false promise and that someone else was expected the next day.

Why had Bessie encouraged Captain Hagberd’s belief?

Answer: She feared that contradicting him would make him miserable or worsen his mental condition. She had also partly believed that his hope might come true.

Quick recap

  • The stranger is Harry, returned to the town after years away.
  • Captain Hagberd expects Harry tomorrow and mistakes his actual son for an impostor.
  • Harry initially suspects a deception involving someone supposedly due to arrive the next day.
  • Bessie stayed silent to protect the Captain from distress and partly shared his hope.
  • The reunion does not happen: Hagberd rejects Harry and throws a shovel at him.
Lecture 6

Bassie’s Persuasion And Harry Leaves Home

Reference video · Lecture 6Bassie’s Persuasion And Harry Leaves Home

Harry proves his identity

  • Harry's return: He says he spent his last shillings on the train fare and his last twopence on a shave, out of respect for his father.
  • Bessie's doubt: She asks if he is really Harry Hagberd. He invites her to judge for herself and she lets him into the garden.
  • Family resemblance: Harry jokes that he looked just like his father as a boy. Bessie recognises the resemblance.
  • Family memories: Harry recalls his father's short coal voyages and asks what his mother died of. Bessie bitterly answers, “From impatience.”

Why Harry left and what he became

  • Family conflict: His mother criticised him for idleness, while his father wanted him to become a lawyer's clerk and forbade him to go to sea.
  • Leaving home: Harry says he was driven away after conflict with his father. He felt he belonged in the open, not in a confined home.
  • Wandering life: In the sixteen years since leaving, he has sailed and worked as a boundary rider, sheep-shearer and gold prospector, among other jobs.
  • Attitude to home: He calls the world his home and would rather live freely—even die outdoors—than settle into the life his father chose for him.

Why Harry has returned

  • Need for money: Harry has returned to ask his father for five pounds because he and his chum are broke after a spree.
  • His chum's suggestion: After seeing the newspaper notice about Harry's loving parent, his chum urged him to go home, believing his father would give him the money.
  • Recent spree: Harry says he had been drinking heavily for three days, deliberately; he insists that drinking is not his usual habit and that he can be steady when he chooses.

Bessie, the sea and the Gambusino song

  • Bessie's situation: Her father calls for her from inside; Harry learns that she is unmarried and caring for him.
  • Freedom and marriage: Harry contrasts the sea's openness with a house's confinement. He says a voyage is not a marriage.
  • Gambusinos: Harry describes restless prospectors who search for gold but leave discoveries behind and cannot be held by home or love.
  • Harry's self-image: He thinks he is like a Gambusino, drawn more to the search and journey than to settling down.
  • Growing attraction: Harry jokes that he loves women but cannot stay with one for long. His compliments leave Bessie flustered, though she notes that he has not seen her face.

Harry Hagberd

  • Restless and adventurous: He has travelled widely and tried many kinds of work.
  • Independent: He rejects the settled career and home his father wanted for him.
  • Sociable and persuasive: He jokes, tells vivid stories and uses playful compliments to charm Bessie.
  • Affectionate but noncommittal: He claims to love women but says no woman can keep him for long.

Bessie Carvil

  • Caring: She responds to her father's call and attends to his needs.
  • Perceptive: She recognises Harry through his resemblance to his father and his family memories.
  • Emotionally affected: Harry's stories and attention unsettle her, though she tries to remain guarded.
Theme

Freedom versus settled domestic life

Harry values movement, the sea and independence over a fixed home or career. The Gambusino story reflects the pull of endless wandering, even when it costs love and belonging.

Theme

Recognition and family ties

Although Harry has been away for sixteen years, his resemblance to his father and his knowledge of family memories connect him to his past and convince Bessie of his identity.

What convinces Bessie that the young man is Harry Hagberd?

Answer: She recognises his strong resemblance to his father and hears him recall family details, including his father's voyages. When Harry asks what his mother died of, Bessie supplies the bitter answer: “From impatience.”

What kind of life had Harry lived after leaving home?

Answer: He had lived as a wanderer, travelling and taking varied jobs, including sailing, sheep-shearing, boundary riding and gold prospecting. He prized adventure and freedom over settling down.

Why has Harry returned to his father's home?

Answer: He and his chum are broke after a spree, so Harry comes to ask his father for five pounds. His chum encouraged him after seeing the newspaper notice about Harry's loving parent.

Quick recap

  • Identity: Bessie recognises Harry through his resemblance to his father and his family memories.
  • Past: Harry left after his parents tried to direct his future and keep him from the sea.
  • Return: Broke after a spree, he comes to ask his father for five pounds, at his chum's urging.
  • Wandering: Harry spent sixteen years travelling and working in different places.
  • Freedom: The Gambusino story captures his urge to keep moving rather than settle down.
  • Bessie: Harry's stories and attention begin to affect her.
Lecture 7

Bassie Tells Harry About His Father’s Plan

Reference video · Lecture 7Bassie Tells Harry About His Father’s Plan

Harry Learns of His Father’s Plan

The Conversation

  • Harry’s hunger: Harry asks Bessie for bread, joking that he asked as a friend, not as a beggar. He complains that he has suffered because of his father’s wishes.
  • Bessie’s explanation: Bessie tells Harry that his father wants him to return, settle down and marry her. She believes she could persuade the old man to change his mind within a week.
  • Harry’s reaction: Harry understands the plan as another attempt to control his life. He believes his father expects him to accept the family money, live quietly at home and marry a girl chosen for him.
  • Hagberd’s interruption: Captain Hagberd sees them at the window. Mistaking Harry for a vagabond, he warns Bessie against him and insists that Harry is coming tomorrow and will marry her.

Characters and Ideas

Harry

  • Independent: He resents his father’s attempts to decide his future.
  • Angry and frustrated: He reacts with contempt to the idea of being confined to a settled life and an arranged marriage.
  • Vulnerable: His hunger and dependence on Bessie’s food reveal his difficult circumstances.

Bessie

  • Caring: She brings Harry food and explains his father’s intentions.
  • Hopeful: She thinks she can persuade Captain Hagberd to accept the situation.
  • Distressed: She sobs quietly as Harry’s anger grows and Hagberd calls from the window.

Captain Hagberd

  • Deluded: He insists that Harry will arrive the next day, despite Harry already being nearby.
  • Controlling: He expects Harry to return, settle down and marry Bessie.
  • Confused: He mistakes Harry for a vagabond and warns Bessie to avoid him.
Theme

Freedom and Control

Harry values independence and rejects his father’s plan to shape his life through money, a home and marriage.

Theme

Delusion and Misunderstanding

Hagberd’s belief that Harry is still coming tomorrow makes him misread the scene and fail to recognise his own son.

Exam Check

What does Bessie tell Harry about his father’s plans?

Answer: His father wants him to return, settle down and marry Bessie. Harry believes his father expects him to accept the family money and live under his control.

What does Captain Hagberd call out to Bessie from the window?

Answer: He warns her to send the vagabond away, insists that Harry is coming tomorrow, and says that Harry will marry her.

Quick recap

  • Bessie tells Harry that his father wants him to return, settle down and marry her.
  • Harry sees the plan as an attempt to control his life.
  • He rejects the idea of living at home and marrying a girl chosen for him.
  • Captain Hagberd mistakes Harry for a vagabond and warns Bessie against him.
  • Hagberd still believes Harry will arrive tomorrow and marry Bessie.
Lecture 8

Facing The Past: Harry’s Emotional Reckoning

Reference video · Lecture 8Facing The Past: Harry’s Emotional Reckoning

The Opening Vow

  • At the opening, a speaker vows to make a man comply; otherwise, he will cut him off with a shilling and leave everything to “you.”
  • The threat of disinheritance introduces the conflict over Harry and the inheritance.

Harry Returns to Bessie

  • Harry recognises Bessie and says he might stay for a week, but quickly reveals that he needs her help to escape his difficulties.
  • Bessie gives him a half-sovereign, ashamed and distressed. Harry insists that money cannot erase their past or buy freedom from it.

Bessie Is Left Behind

  • Harry embraces and kisses Bessie forcefully, leaving her exhausted and emotionally overwhelmed; the scene is compared to a destructive wave from the sea.
  • When he walks away, Bessie follows and calls after him, but receives no answer. The silence makes her feel abandoned and almost lifeless.

The Two Old Men and Bessie’s Return

  • Captain Hagberd mistakes Harry for an “information fellow” and believes Bessie has driven him away. He celebrates, still convinced that tomorrow will bring the promised change.
  • Old Carvil calls Bessie back. Overcome by her situation, she returns to the cottage, while Hagberd’s joyful faith in an endless tomorrow deepens her distress.

Bessie

  • Vulnerable and ashamed: she gives Harry money and wishes she could make him forget their past.
  • Emotionally overwhelmed: after Harry leaves, she calls after him and fears the silence.
  • Trapped by duty and circumstance: she returns when Old Carvil calls.

Harry

  • Self-centred and exploitative: he asks Bessie for money and treats her past attachment as a way out of his troubles.
  • Overpowering: his embrace and kisses are described as forceful, leaving Bessie exhausted.
  • Unmoved by her distress: he leaves without responding to her calls.

Captain Hagberd

  • Deluded and hopeful: he imagines Harry is merely an unwanted visitor and believes tomorrow will make everything right.
  • His triumphant optimism contrasts with Bessie’s pain and shows how his obsession burdens her.
Theme

The Past Cannot Be Bought Away

Bessie’s money cannot erase the history between her and Harry. Their encounter shows that painful memories and emotional consequences cannot simply be paid off.

Theme

False Hope and Emotional Imprisonment

Hagberd’s repeated faith in “one day more” offers no real escape. His hopeful delusion keeps Bessie confined to a life shaped by other people’s needs.

Theme

Abandonment and Silence

Harry’s departure leaves Bessie emotionally isolated. The growing silence around her intensifies her sense of abandonment and despair.

“You can’t buy me in, and you can’t buy yourself out.”

Harry

“One day more.”

Captain Hagberd

Quick recap

  • The opening vow threatens disinheritance: the man will be cut off with a shilling, and everything left to “you.”
  • Harry returns to Bessie, asks for money, and leaves after a forceful encounter.
  • Bessie’s payment cannot erase the past or free her from its emotional consequences.
  • Harry ignores Bessie’s calls, leaving her alone in painful silence.
  • Captain Hagberd misreads what has happened and remains absorbed in his promise of tomorrow.
  • Bessie is caught between Harry’s exploitation, Hagberd’s delusion, and Old Carvil’s demands.
Lecture 9

Exercise

Reference video · Lecture 9Exercise

Story Discussion and Appreciation

Focus of the story questions

  • Key topics: Hagberd’s madness, Bessie’s involvement, Harry’s reasons for returning, and Bessie’s response to his return.
  • Appreciation: Consider how the story reveals Hagberd’s past and how other characters show signs of irrationality.
  • Discussion: The prompts invite reflection on the balance between madness and self-esteem, and a thematic comparison with Joyce’s “Eveline”.

Allusion

Definition

Allusion — An indirect reference to a well-known historical, literary, or mythological person or event.

Example

  • Neptune: Hagberd is compared to Neptune, the Roman god of the sea. His beard and maritime appearance evoke the sea god, while the spade contrasts with Neptune’s trident.

What is an allusion, and what is the effect of the Neptune comparison?

Answer: An allusion indirectly refers to a familiar figure or event. The Neptune comparison links Hagberd’s appearance to the sea god and contrasts his former maritime identity with his spade.

Pronunciation: Word Stress

Stress shifts

  • Word stress: The syllable receiving primary stress can change when a word’s grammatical form changes.
  • Examples: inFORM → inforMAtion; HESitate → hesitaTION.

Suggested reading

  • Joseph Conrad: “An Outpost of Progress” and *Heart of Darkness*.

Quick recap

  • The story questions focus on Hagberd’s madness, Bessie’s involvement, and Harry’s return.
  • Appreciation prompts ask about the unfolding of Hagberd’s past and signs of irrationality in other characters.
  • The discussion invites comparison of “Tomorrow” with Joyce’s “Eveline”.
  • An allusion is an indirect reference; Hagberd is compared with Neptune.
  • Primary stress may shift between related grammatical forms, as in inform/information and hesitate/hesitation.
  • Suggested reading includes Joseph Conrad’s “An Outpost of Progress” and *Heart of Darkness*.

English — ALL CHAPTERS

1

The Last Lesson

View

2

Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)

View

3

Deep Water

View

4

The Rattrap

View

5

Indigo 

View

6

Poets and Pancakes

View

7

The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).

View

8

Going Places

View

9

My Mother at Sixty-six

View

10

Keeping Quiet

View

11

A Thing of Beauty

View

12

A Roadside Stand 

View

13

Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers

View

1

I Sell My Dreams

View

2

Eveline

View

3

A Wedding In Brownsville

View

4

Tomorrow

View

5

One Centimetre 

View

6

A Lecture Upon The Shadow

View

7

Poems By Milton

View

8

Poems By Blake

View

9

Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment

View

10

Trees

View

11

The Wild Swans At Coole

View

12

Time And Time Again

View

13

Blood

View

14

Freedom

View

15

The Mark On The Wall

View

16

Film-making

View

17

Why The Novel Matters

View

18

The Argumentative Indian

View

19

On Science Fiction

View

20

Chandalika

View

21

Broken Images

View

1

The Third Level

View

2

The Tiger King

View

3

Journey to the end of the Earth

View

4

The Enemy

View

5

On The Face Of It

View

6

Memories of Childhood

View