Class 12 PCM . English . Kaleidoscope . Freedom
Chapter 14: Freedom
Ch 14
English
Class 12 PCM
Illusions Of Freedom
Non-Fiction
Non-fiction — Factually true writing outside the categories of novel, short story, play and poem; it includes essays, articles, speeches, reports, biographies and interviews.
George Bernard Shaw
- Dates: 1856–1950; Irish dramatist and critic.
- Critical work: His work as a London music and drama critic led to *The Quintessence of Ibsenism*.
- Famous plays: *Arms and the Man*, *Candida* and *Man and Superman*.
- Style and purpose: He used wit and apparent lightness to challenge muddled thinking and expose hollow pretensions.
The limits of personal freedom
- Shaw argues that perfect freedom—doing anything, at any time and place—is impossible because everyone must meet basic needs such as sleeping, eating and travelling.
- Natural necessities: These require unavoidable work, but producing food, shelter and clothing creates labour that others may exploit.
- Exploitation: People can shift their own necessary work onto others through force, deception or beliefs that persuade people to surrender their freedom.
Government, work and the vote
- Shaw’s claim: If people or groups gain power over others, they can transfer much of their own necessary labour onto them, forcing long working hours.
- Ideal government: Its purpose should be to prevent people from imposing this burden on others; Shaw argues that many actual governments instead enforce and regulate exploitation.
- Wage slavery: When chattel slavery became less profitable, workers were offered a choice of employers. Shaw argues that this choice could mean little more than choosing a different master.
- Limited democracy: Elections let voters choose between candidates, but Shaw says this does not necessarily reduce working hours or change their economic position.
Natural needs and human exploitation
- Natural slavery: Nature’s demands, such as eating and sleeping, are also pleasurable, so people generally welcome their satisfaction.
- Human-made slavery: Exploitation by other people is harmful to both body and spirit; it produces conflict between workers and employers, which Shaw describes as class war.
- Proposed remedy: Shaw draws on Karl Marx’s critique of exploitation and Thomas More’s ideal of a society where everyone contributes their own labour instead of forcing others to do it.
Stories used to disguise inequality
- National claims: Shaw argues that people are taught to associate freedom with events such as Magna Carta, the defeat of the Spanish Armada, the Bill of Rights and the American Declaration of Independence.
- Reforms and voting: When people question their hardship, they are reminded of the vote, factory laws, education and welfare. Shaw counters that these do not erase the burden of long work and rent.
- Critics of the system: Shaw names writers including Voltaire, Rousseau, Tom Paine, Cobbett, Shelley, Marx, Lassalle, Lenin and Trotsky, whose challenges to established power were often attacked or suppressed.
- Revolutions: Shaw says governments may oppose revolutions to restore the old order, but may later accept revolutionary leaders when their states become powerful; he cites Russia’s revolution and the year 1922.
Freedom and economic power
Shaw questions the idea that political rights alone make people free. In his argument, genuine freedom also requires protection from having one person’s necessary labour imposed on another.
How are natural necessities linked to labour and slavery in Shaw’s argument?
What should be the purpose of government, and what does Shaw accuse many governments of doing?
Quick recap
- Perfect freedom is impossible because everyone has unavoidable natural needs.
- Shaw distinguishes necessary work from exploitation by other people.
- He argues that those in power can transfer their labour onto workers.
- Voting and choosing an employer may not remove economic dependence.
- Shaw presents class conflict as a result of human exploitation.
- He urges a society in which everyone contributes their share of work.
Truth About Liberty
Education and the Class System
- Unequal beliefs: Elite education can delude the master class more deeply than workers by teaching privileged people to see themselves as naturally superior.
- Workers’ experience: Low wages, insecure housing and inferior treatment make workers less convinced that the existing system is fair.
- Political change: In hardship, anger may lead workers to support a powerful leader or emperor; changing rulers does not necessarily bring freedom.
Power, Obedience and Human Nature
- Aristotle’s view, as presented here: Law, order and government supposedly depend on common people seeing their rulers as superior and obeying them.
- Manufactured superiority: Rulers are made to seem almost godlike through wealth, fine dress, uniforms, special manners and servants who do everyday tasks for them.
- Voting example: Workers may not vote for candidates from their own class; the speaker also cites women voters choosing a wealthy, titled woman over worker-rights candidates.
- Changeable attitudes: One view treats class behaviour as fixed human nature; the opposing view says education and propaganda shape attitudes from childhood and could be changed.
Production and the Limits of Freedom
- Central economic question: The practical issue is how the country’s income and output should be distributed.
- Potential for equality: If modern farms and factories produce enough, an equal distribution could provide unskilled workers as much as managers and scientific staff.
- Limits of production: Machinery can greatly increase output, but goods such as needles, pins and matches cannot meet basic needs like food or clothing.
- Limits of nature: Technology can improve farming, but exploiting natural resources too heavily may bring harmful consequences.
- Natural needs: Freedom cannot mean doing anything at every moment; people must meet basic needs and work to support themselves or rely on someone else’s earnings.
Laws, Employers and Trade Unions
- Law and freedom: Laws restrict some actions, but reasonable laws applied impartially protect people from violence, robbery and disorder.
- Economic dependence: Landlords may control where people live and how they act; employers may control clothing and working hours or dismiss workers into unemployment.
- Trade Union response: The strike is presented as workers’ main means of resisting unfair treatment, though a general strike could cause widespread suffering and threaten everyone’s survival.
- Sane union action: The speaker favours one major strike at a time, supported by workers in other trades, rather than a simultaneous general strike.
Leisure, Money and the Meaning of Freedom
- Freedom as leisure: The speaker says to call freedom by its old English name, leisure—time free from work to use as one chooses.
- Practical leisure: Free time depends on working hours, physical tiredness, the law and having enough money to enjoy books, films or other interests.
- The speaker’s proposal: People should demand more leisure and enough money to enjoy it, in return for an honest share of work.
- Political warning: A vote and relief payments alone do not provide meaningful freedom; the speaker says politics must change.
- Warning about candidates: The speaker urges people not to vote for candidates who speak of freedom and liberty, arguing that they are effectively anarchists seeking to live off workers’ labour without punishment.
- Using leisure: More free time is not automatically beneficial if people have not learned how to use it well. The essay ends by comparing retirement at forty-five after longer workdays with shorter workdays continuing until seventy.
Freedom and Economic Power
Freedom is more than political rights: natural needs, poverty and dependence on employers or landlords limit everyday choices. The speaker links meaningful freedom to more leisure and a fairer share of income.
Education and Social Attitudes
The essay questions whether obedience and class hierarchy are natural or produced by education and propaganda. It suggests that different education could shape different social attitudes.
Why, according to the speaker, can the master class be more deluded than workers?
According to the speaker, how can reasonable, impartially administered laws contribute to freedom?
What are the main ways individual freedom is restricted in the essay?
Quick recap
- Elite education can encourage privileged people to accept class inequality as deserved.
- The essay debates whether class attitudes are natural or shaped by education and propaganda.
- If modern production is sufficient, equal distribution could provide unskilled workers as much as managers and scientific staff.
- Reasonable laws can restrict actions while protecting people from harm and disorder.
- Landlords, employers, poverty and natural needs can limit freedom in everyday life.
- The speaker calls freedom leisure and urges people to seek more leisure and money for a fair share of work.
- The speaker warns against candidates who promise freedom while, in his view, intending to live off workers’ labour.
Understanding Freedom And Discipline
J. Krishnamurti
- Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895–1986) was a writer and speaker on philosophical and spiritual subjects.
- He explored meditation, human relationships and positive change in society.
- His ideas on education are reflected in independent schools supported by non-profit foundations.
Discipline, Freedom and Tradition
- People often expect discipline and resistance to lead to freedom, but Krishnamurti argues that genuine freedom is needed to think, explore and discover.
- Tradition, social expectations and accepted ideas can form an invisible prison. Following them without examination is conformity, not freedom.
- A person must question inherited values and investigate for themselves rather than blindly follow even an admired teacher or guide.
Inquiry, Intelligence and Inner Conflict
- Real inquiry requires alert perception and sustained effort; simply relying on a guru or teacher prevents independent discovery.
- Young people need room to question and find their own direction. Constant rules can weaken intelligence and encourage thoughtless conformity.
- Intelligence grows when the mind is free to question, think and discover. It helps a person act inwardly and outwardly with clarity rather than fear.
- Society’s traditions and parents’ expectations can clash with a young person’s own wishes, creating inner conflict, pain and frustration.
- Krishnamurti sees discipline and freedom as contradictory: genuine freedom brings understanding that helps a person see why certain actions should not be taken.
Freedom, Sensitivity and Compassion
- Young people should begin discovering their interests and taking initiative early in life; this is the seed of future freedom and happiness.
- Self-absorption and class prejudice can make people ignore the hardship of villagers and workers, such as women carrying heavy loads or a servant carrying a carpet.
- Sensitivity means noticing the world, appreciating beauty and responding with sympathy and affection to people who suffer.
- Fear of parents, teachers, tradition and life gradually dulls sensitivity. So do self-interest, imitation and excessive concern with appearance.
- Real freedom requires sensitivity and intelligence. These qualities help people face life’s problems.
Freedom Through Independent Inquiry
Freedom is not achieved through imposed rules or imitation. It grows when people question tradition, discover for themselves and develop an alert, intelligent mind.
Sensitivity and Concern for Others
Freedom includes being aware of the world and compassionate towards those who suffer. Fear, conformity and self-concern close the mind and weaken sensitivity.
Why do many people find it easier to conform, imitate and follow a guru?
What is the inward struggle described by Krishnamurti?
Quick recap
- Discipline based on resistance and imposed rules does not create genuine freedom.
- Tradition becomes a prison when people accept its values without questioning them.
- Independent inquiry develops intelligence and helps young people find their own direction.
- Clashing personal wishes and social expectations can create inner conflict.
- Fear, imitation and self-concern dull sensitivity and compassion.
- Freedom involves alert intelligence, awareness and concern for others.
Exercise
Sentence Types
Sentence Structure
- Sentence: A meaningful unit made up of one or more clauses.
- Clause: A group of words organised around a verb; a clause consists of one or more phrases.
- Phrase: A group of words functioning together; a phrase consists of one or more words.
- Main clause: Can stand independently; a subordinate clause depends on another clause for its meaning.
| Type | Structure | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Simple | One main clause. | Nature is kind to her slaves. |
| Complex | One main clause and at least one subordinate clause. | As we must eat, we must first provide food. |
| Compound | Two or more main clauses joined together, often by a conjunction. | You are all young, but I don’t think you are too young to be aware of this. |
To analyse a long sentence, find its verbs and identify the main clause first; then connect each subordinate clause to the clause it depends on.
Rhetorical Questions
Rhetorical question — A question asked to make a point or persuade, rather than to receive an answer.
How They Work
- Implied answer: The reader supplies the mental answer the speaker intends.
- Positive question: Implies a negative statement; a negative question implies a positive statement.
- Effect: Rhetorical questions engage the audience and can challenge assumptions or stir concern.
Pronunciation: Sound Sequences
Vowels and Consonants
- Vowel sound (V): Can occur alone or at the centre of a sequence of sounds.
- Consonant sound (C): Cannot occur alone and typically occurs at the edge of a sound sequence.
- Sound sequence: Shows the order of vowel and consonant sounds in a word, not the number of letters.
- Examples: “I” = V; “see” = CV; “train” = CCVC; “boat” = CVC.
- Digraphs: The letters “ee” in “see”, “ai” in “train”, and “oa” in “boat” each represent one vowel sound.
Do not count vowel letters to find a sound pattern: count the sounds heard. Two letters can represent a single vowel sound.
Quick recap
- A sentence contains one or more clauses; clauses contain phrases, and phrases contain words.
- Simple sentences have one main clause; complex sentences include subordinate clauses; compound sentences join main clauses.
- In long sentences, locate the main clause before analysing dependent clauses.
- Rhetorical questions make a point or persuade instead of requesting information.
- Vowel sounds are marked V and consonant sounds C; patterns represent sounds, not letters.
- Examples: “I” = V, “see” = CV, “train” = CCVC, and “boat” = CVC.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood