Class 12 PCM . English . Flamingo . The Interview From the Introduction to the Penguin Book of Interviews Edited By Christopher Silvester
Chapter 7: The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
Ch 7
English
Class 12 PCM
Reasons Celebrities Dislike Interviews
Christopher Silvester
- Born in 1959; studied history at Peterhouse, Cambridge.
- Worked as a reporter for Private Eye for ten years and wrote features for Vanity Fair.
- This extract is from his introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews, an anthology covering 1859 to the present.
Interviews: value and controversy
Part I: Why interviews are disputed
- The interview was invented a little over 130 years ago and has since become commonplace in journalism; literate readers and thousands of celebrities have encountered it, often repeatedly.
- Some see a good interview as a source of truth and an art; others, especially celebrities, regard it as intrusive and diminishing.
- Some cultures believe a portrait steals part of a person's soul; the passage compares this with the feeling that an interview can take something from its subject.
- V. S. Naipaul felt that interviews could wound people and make them lose part of themselves.
- Lewis Carroll dreaded interviewers and avoided them, partly because he disliked being lionised and approached by strangers.
| Person | Attitude or example |
|---|---|
| Rudyard Kipling | Called interviews immoral, cowardly and vile, comparing them to an assault. His wife recorded the complaint in her diary on 14 October 1892; ironically, Kipling had interviewed Mark Twain. |
| H. G. Wells | Called an interview an ordeal in 1894, yet was a frequent interviewee and later interviewed Joseph Stalin. |
| Saul Bellow | Compared interviews to thumbprints pressing on his windpipe, although he had agreed to interviews. |
| Denis Brian | Argued that interviews shape vivid impressions of people and give interviewers exceptional influence. |
The importance of the interview
Despite its drawbacks, the interview is a powerful means of communication. It informs the public about people and gives interviewers considerable influence.
Umberto Eco: scholar and novelist
Part II: One set of interests, many kinds of writing
- Umberto Eco was a professor at the University of Bologna, known for work on semiotics, literary interpretation and medieval aesthetics.
- He wrote scholarship, essays, fiction, children's books and newspaper articles; he saw the same ethical and philosophical interests across them.
- Eco called gaps or spare moments in daily life “interstices” and used them productively, sometimes writing while waiting for an elevator.
- A professor praised Eco's first doctoral dissertation for narrating the research process, including its trials and errors; Eco later used this approach in his essays.
- Eco began writing novels by chance at about fifty, finding that they suited his interest in storytelling. He had not felt frustrated about not being a novelist.
Umberto Eco
- Productive: used short intervals of spare time for writing.
- Intellectually consistent: pursued related ethical and philosophical ideas across different kinds of work.
- Narrative-minded: presented academic research as a story and later wrote novels.
- Secure in his identity: considered himself an academic, though he knew novels reached more readers.
The Name of the Rose and its success
- Published in 1980, The Name of the Rose made Eco internationally famous; it combines detective fiction with metaphysics, theology and medieval history.
- Eco was not surprised that readers enjoyed a demanding novel: people may seek light entertainment at times but do not always want easy reading.
- Eco had written five novels and over forty scholarly works; the novel sold between 10 and 15 million copies overall.
- Its American publisher expected 3,000 copies, but it eventually sold two or three million in the United States.
- Eco called the novel's success a mystery and believed its reception might have differed if it had appeared ten years earlier or later.
Academic identity and popular success
Eco identified primarily with the academic community, even though his novels made him widely known. Fiction let him reach more readers without replacing his scholarship.
- Commonplace
- Ordinary or frequently encountered.
- Intrusion
- An unwelcome entry into someone's private life.
- Lionised
- Treated as a celebrity or hero.
- Ordeal
- A difficult or unpleasant experience.
- Interstice
- A small gap or interval of free time.
- Semiotics
- The study of signs and how they communicate meaning.
- Metaphysics
- The branch of philosophy that studies the nature of reality.
- Yarn
- An informal word for a story.
What are the contrasting views of interviews presented in Part I?
What did Eco mean by “interstices,” and how did he use them?
How did Eco explain the success of The Name of the Rose?
Quick recap
- The interview was invented a little over 130 years ago and has become commonplace in journalism.
- Some celebrities feel interviews invade privacy, expose them to unwanted attention or diminish their sense of self.
- Despite objections, interviews powerfully shape public impressions and communicate information.
- Eco saw scholarship, fiction and other writing as expressions of connected ethical and philosophical interests.
- He used spare moments—“interstices”—and developed a narrative style in both scholarship and fiction.
- Eco identified as an academic while recognising that novels brought his ideas to a wider audience.
- The success of The Name of the Rose showed that readers welcome challenging books, though success is difficult to predict.
Exercise
Reviewing the Interview
- Text-based questions: The exercise asks about Eco’s attitude to interviews, writing routine, academic style, identity as a novelist or scholar, and the success of *The Name of the Rose*.
- Eco appears to enjoy interviews, answering openly and illustrating his ideas with stories. He writes in the empty spaces, or “interstices,” of his day; his academic writing is personal and narrative, recounting the research process and its trials and errors. He considers himself a university professor who writes novels on Sundays. The success of The Name of the Rose remains a mystery, though its serious subject matter found readers and its timing may have mattered.
Linkers and Signallers
Linker — A word or phrase that connects one utterance or idea to another.
- Reference words: “That”, “this” and “which” can refer back to an earlier idea.
- Repetition: Repeating a word or phrase can link speakers’ turns, as in “Over 40.”
- Purpose: Linkers maintain continuity in conversation, especially in a structured conversation such as an interview.
Signaller — A phrase that prepares listeners for a shift in topic or direction.
- Examples: “Which brings me to another question” and “But let me tell you another story” signal topic shifts.
- Purpose: Signallers make changes in direction clear and help keep the conversation smooth.
Interview Discussion and Report Writing
- Understanding interviews: An interview can add to understanding of the celebrity, the interviewer and the celebrity’s field.
- Medium: Print, radio and television are possible formats for interviews.
- Privacy: Famous people have a right to privacy; interviewers’ very personal questions can embarrass them.
- Short report: If a verbatim transcript cannot be published, report the interview’s salient points concisely instead of reproducing every exchange.
- Interview practice: Interview someone you admire in school or your neighbourhood, then record the conversation in writing.
Quick recap
- Eco found time to write in the “interstices” of his day and saw his scholarly work and novels as expressions of the same interests.
- Linkers connect utterances through reference words or repetition.
- Signallers prepare listeners for a change of topic.
- A short interview report presents the salient points, not a verbatim transcript.
- Interview discussions can consider media, understanding and the interviewee’s right to privacy.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood