Class 12 PCM . English . Kaleidoscope . On Science Fiction
Chapter 19: On Science Fiction
Ch 19
English
Class 12 PCM
Worlds of Wonder
Isaac Asimov
- Russian-born American author and biochemist (1920–1992).
- A highly prolific writer, best known for science fiction and popular-science books.
- His popular-science writing often explains ideas through their historical development.
- His name is associated with *Asimov’s Science Fiction* magazine.
The rise of science fiction
Why science fiction is modern
- Asimov argues that true science fiction imagines a future changed by advances in science and technology.
- This idea became possible when scientific and technological change was rapid enough to be noticed within a person’s lifetime.
- That change gathered pace with the Industrial Revolution, around 1800; science fiction developed afterwards.
- Earlier tales of the strange and powerful met similar emotional needs, but belonged to a prescientific world-view.
Myths and the prescientific universe
How people once explained nature
- In prescientific times, people generally did not understand nature as governed by fixed, impersonal laws.
- They imagined natural events as the actions of powerful beings, often human-like or made from combinations of familiar animals.
- Gods were often seen as unpredictable, easily offended, but also capable of kindness when properly treated.
- People believed that prayers or magical formulas could influence the gods; failed results could be blamed on someone having offended them.
- Priests, magicians, wizards and shamans therefore filled a role similar to that of scientists: they were thought to possess ways of controlling the universe.
Ancient wonders and modern science fiction
- Myths offered extraordinary powers and experiences: winged horses and flying carpets enabled flight; crystal balls and magic shells resembled distant seeing and hearing.
- ‘Open sesame’ and seven-league boots evoke automatic doors and rapid travel.
- Mythical beings such as centaurs, satyrs, sphinxes, harpies, gryphons and gorgons combine familiar animal or human forms.
- Science-fiction extraterrestrials are often imagined through a similar combination of familiar features.
- Both myths and science fiction portray life unlike our own and satisfy the human longing for wonder.
| Point | Mythological fiction | Science fiction |
|---|---|---|
| Universe | Governed by gods and demons | Governed by impersonal, consistent laws of nature |
| How power is gained | Through prayers, enchantments or magical formulas | Through understanding and using natural laws |
| Shared purpose | Depicts unfamiliar life and creates wonder | Depicts unfamiliar life and creates wonder |
The value of prescientific stories
Asimov’s view
- Science fiction is more valid as an account of how the real universe works because nature appears to follow laws, not the wishes of gods or demons.
- However, Asimov warns against dismissing myths simply because their universes do not match reality; literature can be enjoyable beyond its factual accuracy.
- Mythological adventures and science-fiction adventures use different kinds of universes but can follow similar exciting paths.
- Asimov keeps a narrow definition of science fiction: sword-and-sorcery is not science fiction, but can be its equivalent in a prescientific universe.
- Such stories need not be given a scientific-sounding explanation; they should be consistent within their own universe, well-written and exciting.
The human longing for wonder
Myths and science fiction both satisfy our desire to imagine lives and powers beyond ordinary experience. Their key difference is whether the universe is explained through magic or through natural laws.
- Prescientific
- Belonging to a time before nature was understood through modern science.
- Whimsical
- Unpredictable or guided by sudden changes of mood.
- Placate
- To calm or satisfy someone who is angry.
- Supernormal
- Beyond what is considered ordinary or natural.
- Aeronavigation
- Travel or navigation through the air.
- Analogous
- Similar in function or relationship, though not identical.
- Unswervable
- Not capable of being changed or turned aside.
- Self-consistent
- Following rules that do not contradict one another within a story.
What parallel does Asimov draw between ancient myths and science fiction?
What gives science fiction its validity, according to Asimov?
Which works does Asimov evoke with ‘Open sesame’, winged horses and flying carpets?
Quick recap
- Asimov places the rise of true science fiction after the Industrial Revolution, when technological change became noticeable.
- Ancient myths met similar needs by imagining extraordinary beings, powers and adventures.
- In prescientific thought, people sought to influence nature through gods, prayers and magical formulas.
- Science fiction relies on understanding and applying consistent natural laws.
- Myths and science fiction differ in their imagined universes but both offer wonder and adventure.
- Asimov accepts prescientific stories as a literary equivalent when they are self-consistent, well-written and exciting.
The Universe of Science Fiction
Foreword
- The narrator introduces an essay written for the anthology *The 13 Crimes of Science Fiction* (1979), co-edited with Martin Harry Greenberg and Charles G. Waugh.
- The essay explores how science fiction can combine with other kinds of writing, especially mystery stories.
Science Fiction as a Background
Science fiction — A kind of literature defined mainly by its imagined scientific or social background, rather than by one particular type of plot.
Genres Can Enter a Science-Fiction Setting
- A sports story, Western or jungle story is usually identified by its content; placing it in a significantly different society adds science fiction without removing its original genre.
- A space-station contest using a gas gun and sphere can be both a sports story and science fiction.
- A fishboy herding mackerel and cod with a dolphin can preserve the spirit of a Western in a different setting that also makes it science fiction.
- A jungle on another planet can retain the dangers of a jungle story while adding unfamiliar environmental hazards.
- Even a serious novel about human nature can be science fiction if interplanetary travel is common in its society and part of its plot.
| Point | Content | Background |
|---|---|---|
| Role | Provides the central activity or subject, such as sport, cattle herding or danger in a jungle. | Provides the society and setting in which the story unfolds. |
| Effect of a science-fiction setting | The original genre can remain unchanged. | An imagined society or environment makes the story science fiction too. |
Science-Fiction Mysteries
The Fair-Play Challenge
- John Campbell maintained that a science-fiction mystery was impossible because its broad possibilities could make the classical mystery’s fair-play rules hard to uphold.
- The narrator guesses Campbell may have feared a sudden, unexplained change in the story’s rules, such as a previously undisclosed Q-ray that solves the mystery.
- Ordinary mysteries can also be unfair if a detective’s extraordinary abilities advance the plot without a convincing basis.
Scientific Accuracy and Extrapolation
- Mystery writers may use real scientific findings unfamiliar to readers, but they must understand the science to avoid errors.
- John Dickson Carr confused the element antimony with the compound antimony potassium tartrate; he also confused carbon monoxide with carbon dioxide.
- Dorothy Sayers used thyroid hormones in a story but portrayed their effects as far too rapid and extreme.
- Science-fiction writers face an added challenge: they need sound scientific knowledge and a rational way to extend or modify it.
Rules for a Fair Science-Fiction Mystery
- A science-fiction mystery is difficult, but not impossible; its setting may include telepathy, light-speed mass transport or computerized knowledge.
- The writer must clearly establish the imagined society’s limits: what can be done and what cannot.
- Readers should receive the relevant observations and clues available to the investigator; misdirection and red herrings are acceptable, but the solution must remain inferable.
- The narrator cites *The Caves of Steel* and *The Naked Sun*, his science-fiction mysteries written in the 1950s, as examples showing the form can work.
The Range of Science Fiction
Science fiction can combine with many genres and even serious literature. Its imagined setting must remain coherent, especially when readers are expected to solve a mystery.
How does the narrator distinguish science fiction from genres such as sports stories or Westerns?
What conditions make a science-fiction mystery fair to the reader?
Quick recap
- Science fiction is defined mainly by its background, not by a single kind of plot.
- A story can belong to another genre and still be science fiction.
- The narrator presents science-fiction mysteries as difficult but possible.
- Writers must understand the science they use and extend it rationally.
- Readers should know the setting’s rules and receive the investigator’s relevant clues.
- The narrator points to *The Caves of Steel* and *The Naked Sun* as examples.
Exercise
Understanding the Text
Question Focus
- Genre distinction: Consider what distinguishes science fiction from other fiction genres.
- Science-fiction mystery: The questions ask how Asimov responds to John Campbell’s view about fairness to readers.
- Writing pitfalls: Be prepared to identify the problems a writer of science-fiction mysteries must guard against, using the essay.
Discussion and Appreciation
Discussion Topics
- Imagination and fantasy: Discuss how they help people speculate about complex and unpredictable phenomena in the universe.
- Science fiction and change: Discuss the claim that science fiction imagined some changes to everyday life before they occurred.
Appreciation Focus
- Tone: Examine the author’s attitude towards pre-scientific imagination and the tone used to describe it.
- Paragraphs: Consider why some paragraphs consist of a single sentence and what effect this form creates.
- Discourse markers: Identify linkers that connect one paragraph’s point to the next; “Let me explain” is an example from the essay.
Literary Allusions
References to Research
- Mythical creatures: The exercise names the Centaur, Satyr, Sphinx, Harpy, Gryphon, Gorgon and Pegasus for research, including possible parallels in Indian mythology.
- Classical story: The exercise asks students to find out about the story of Achilles and Hector.
Pronunciation: Pauses and Tone Groups
- English rhythm: Speech rhythm depends on word stress and sentence stress; both contribute to intelligibility.
- Tone group: A stretch of speech spoken in one breath. A pause between groups can be marked with `/`.
- Length: Tone groups average about two seconds or five words, but may contain one word or as many as seven or eight.
- Pauses: Group spoken language by breath and thought; the pace and information in each group reflect the speaker’s thoughts.
Grammar: Verb Classes
| Feature | Rule |
|---|---|
| Transitive verb | Generally takes a noun phrase as its object. |
| Finding an object | Identify the noun phrase that follows and completes the verb’s meaning. |
| Passive form | The object of an active transitive verb can become the subject in a passive construction. |
| Example | Active: “He expected a sudden change of rules.” Passive: “A sudden change of rules was expected by him.” |
| Verb “have” | In the passage, have is followed by a noun phrase; sentences with have do not usually have a passive form. |
That-Clauses
- That-clause: A clause introduced by “that” can follow a verb and complete its meaning.
- Examples of verbs: The exercise names ask, believe, know, realise and promise as verbs to look for with that-clauses.
Suggested Reading
- Isaac Asimov: *Foundation*.
- Isaac Asimov: *Chronology of Science and Discovery*.
Quick recap
- The text’s comprehension prompts focus on genre, fairness in science-fiction mysteries and writers’ pitfalls.
- Discussion questions consider imagination, speculation and science fiction’s vision of change.
- Appreciation tasks focus on tone, single-sentence paragraphs and discourse markers.
- English rhythm uses word stress and sentence stress; tone groups are separated by pauses.
- Transitive verbs take objects that can generally become the subjects of passive constructions; have is not usually passivised.
- Some verbs, including ask, believe, know, realise and promise, can be followed by that-clauses.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood