Class 12 Commerce . Accountancy . Partnership Accounts . Dissolution of Partnership Firm
Chapter 4: Dissolution of Partnership Firm
Ch 4
Accountancy
Class 12 Commerce
Dissolution of Partnership & Dissolution of Firm
Dissolution of Partnership
- Dissolution of partnership: It changes the relationship among partners; the firm may continue its business.
- Events: It may result from a change in profit-sharing ratio, admission, retirement, death or insolvency of a partner, or completion or expiry of the partnership.
Dissolution of a Firm
| Basis | Dissolution of partnership | Dissolution of firm |
|---|---|---|
| Business | Business is not necessarily terminated; the firm may continue. | The firm’s business is closed. |
| Assets and liabilities | Assets and liabilities are revalued and a new balance sheet is drawn. | Assets are sold and liabilities are paid. |
| Court intervention | Usually arises from changes in partners’ relationship and does not require court intervention. | May occur by a court order on specified grounds. |
| Economic relationship | Partners’ economic relationship may continue in a changed form. | Partners’ economic relationship comes to an end. |
| Books of account | Books need not be closed if the business continues. | Books are closed as the firm is wound up. |
Dissolution of a firm necessarily dissolves the partnership, but dissolution of a partnership does not necessarily dissolve the firm.
Is this dissolution of partnership, dissolution of the firm, or both?
- A partner retires, and the remaining partners continue the same business.
- Retirement changes the partners’ relationship, so the existing partnership is dissolved.
- Because the business continues, the firm itself is not necessarily dissolved.
Do not use the two terms interchangeably: dissolution of partnership may leave the firm operating, while dissolution of a firm ends the partnership between all partners.
Modes of Dissolution of a Firm
| Mode | Grounds and conditions |
|---|---|
| By agreement | All partners consent, or dissolution takes place according to the partners’ contract. |
| Compulsory dissolution | All partners, or all but one, become insolvent and incompetent to contract; or the firm’s business becomes illegal. |
| Unlawful business | An event makes it unlawful for the partners to carry on the business together, such as war making a partner an alien enemy. |
| Specified contingencies | Subject to the partners’ contract: expiry of a fixed term, completion of a venture, death of a partner, or adjudication of a partner as insolvent. |
| By notice | In a partnership at will, any partner may dissolve the firm by giving the other partners written notice of their intention. |
| By court | At a partner’s suit, the court may order dissolution on specified grounds. |
Grounds for Dissolution by Court
- Incapacity: A partner becomes insane or permanently incapable of performing their duties.
- Misconduct: A partner’s conduct is likely to adversely affect the firm’s business.
- Breach: A partner persistently commits a breach of the partnership agreement.
- Transfer: A partner transfers their whole interest in the firm to a third party.
- Losses: The business cannot be carried on except at a loss.
- Just and equitable: The court considers dissolution fair and appropriate on another ground.
True or false: (a) Dissolution of a firm necessarily involves dissolution of partnership. (b) Dissolution of partnership necessarily dissolves the firm.
State whether each case dissolves a firm compulsorily: (a) one partner decides to retire; (b) all partners become insolvent; (c) the firm’s business becomes illegal.
Name any four grounds on which a court may order dissolution of a firm.
Quick recap
- Dissolution of partnership changes the partners’ relationship; the firm may continue.
- Section 39 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 defines dissolution of a firm as dissolution of partnership between all partners.
- Dissolution of a firm ends ordinary business and begins winding up: assets are sold, liabilities paid and claims settled.
- A firm may dissolve by agreement, compulsorily, on specified contingencies, by notice or by court order.
- In a partnership at will, any partner may dissolve the firm by written notice to the others.
- Court grounds include insanity, permanent incapacity, misconduct, persistent breach, transfer of the whole interest, continuing only at a loss, or a just and equitable ground.
Settlement of Accounts
Rules for Settling Accounts (Section 48)
Order of Applying Available Funds
- Realised assets + any partner contributions
- Pay firm debts to outsiders (secured debts before unsecured debts)
- Repay partner loans and advances
- Settle partners’ capital balances
- Distribute any residue in the profit-sharing ratio
A firm has Rs. 70 available after realisation. Outside debts are Rs. 30, a partner loan is Rs. 10, and capital due is Rs. 30 to A and Rs. 20 to B. How is the amount settled?
- After paying outside debts of Rs. 30 and a partner loan of Rs. 10 from Rs. 70 available, Rs. 30 remains for capital.
- Capital due is Rs. 30 to A and Rs. 20 to B. Distribute the Rs. 30 available proportionately to capital due.
Use when funds available for a class of claims are insufficient to pay those claims in full. Here, is the amount available, is the amount due to a claimant, and is the total amount due.
A firm has Rs. 50 available. Outside debts are Rs. 24, a partner loan is Rs. 6, and capital due is Rs. 12 to A and Rs. 18 to B. How much capital can each partner receive?
Firm Debts and Private Debts (Section 49)
The partner’s remaining private property after meeting private debts may be available towards unpaid firm debts. Let be net private assets, private assets and private liabilities.
A partner has private assets of Rs. 50 and private liabilities of Rs. 20. Firm assets are insufficient to pay firm debts. What amount of the partner’s private property may be available for firm debts?
- Apply the partner’s private property to their own private debts first.
- The remaining Rs. 30 is net private property and may be used towards firm debts if firm assets are inadequate.
A partner’s private assets are Rs. 80 and private debts are Rs. 35. Firm assets cannot fully pay firm liabilities. What is the partner’s net private property potentially available for firm debts?
A Partner’s Inability to Contribute
In the absence of an agreement to the contrary, share the unrecoverable deficiency among solvent partners by their capitals at dissolution. Let be the loss borne by a solvent partner, the unrecoverable deficiency, and and the partner’s capital and total solvent partners’ capital at dissolution.
A is insolvent and cannot pay a deficiency of Rs. 12. B and C are solvent, with capitals of Rs. 60 and Rs. 40 at dissolution. How is the deficiency shared under Garner v. Murray?
- A’s unrecoverable deficiency is Rs. 12. B and C are solvent, with capitals at dissolution of Rs. 60 and Rs. 40.
- Share the deficiency between B and C in the ratio of their capitals.
A partner’s unrecoverable deficiency is Rs. 15. The two solvent partners’ capitals at dissolution are Rs. 40 and Rs. 60. How is the loss shared, assuming no contrary agreement?
- Section 48: outsiders → partner loans → capital → residue.
- Section 49: firm property pays firm debts first; private property pays private debts first.
- Garner v. Murray: absent an agreement, solvent partners share an insolvent partner’s deficiency by capitals at dissolution.
Quick recap
- Section 48 sets the default order for settling losses and applying firm assets, unless partners agree otherwise.
- Firm debts to third parties are paid before partner loans; partner loans are paid before capital.
- Insufficient funds for a class of claim are distributed proportionately among the amounts due in that class.
- Any surplus after settling claims is shared in the profit-sharing ratio.
- Under Section 49, firm property first pays firm debts and a partner’s private property first pays that partner’s private debts.
- An insolvent partner’s unrecoverable capital deficiency is a firm loss.
- Under Garner v. Murray, solvent partners bear that loss in the ratio of their capitals at dissolution, unless agreed otherwise.
Accounting Treatment
Realisation Account
Realisation Account — An account prepared on dissolution to record the disposal of assets and settlement of external liabilities, and to calculate the resulting profit or loss.
Purpose and Main Entries
- Purpose: Close the firm’s books and find the net result of realising assets and paying liabilities.
- Transfer assets: Debit Realisation Account and credit the relevant asset accounts; exclude cash/bank and fictitious assets.
- Transfer external liabilities: Debit liability accounts and credit Realisation Account.
- Record disposal and settlement: Credit Realisation Account for asset proceeds; debit it for liabilities paid and realisation expenses.
- Partner takes over an asset: Debit the partner’s Capital Account and credit Realisation Account.
- Partner assumes a liability: Debit Realisation Account and credit the partner’s Capital Account.
- Result: Transfer realisation profit or loss to partners’ Capital Accounts in their profit-sharing ratio.
| Transaction | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer assets (excluding cash/bank and fictitious assets) | Realisation A/c | Individual asset accounts |
| Transfer external liabilities | Individual liability accounts | Realisation A/c |
| Sell an asset | Bank | Realisation A/c |
| Partner takes over an asset | Partner’s Capital A/c | Realisation A/c |
| Pay a transferred liability | Realisation A/c | Bank |
| Partner assumes a liability | Realisation A/c | Partner’s Capital A/c |
| Pay realisation expenses from firm’s bank | Realisation A/c | Bank |
| Transfer realisation profit | Realisation A/c | Partners’ Capital A/cs |
| Transfer realisation loss | Partners’ Capital A/cs | Realisation A/c |
Other Dissolution Treatments
- Cash and bank: Not transferred to Realisation Account; used to settle payments and final balances.
- Bank overdraft: An external liability transferred to Realisation Account.
- Partner’s loan: Not transferred to Realisation Account or Capital Account; it is settled separately according to the dissolution rules.
- Provision for doubtful debts: In the illustration, debit the Provision account and credit Realisation Account.
- Reserves and accumulated profits: Transfer directly to partners’ Capital Accounts in the profit-sharing ratio.
- Unrecorded asset sold: Debit Bank and credit Realisation Account; if a partner takes it, debit that partner’s Capital Account and credit Realisation Account.
- Unrecorded liability paid: Debit Realisation Account and credit Bank; if a partner assumes it, credit that partner’s Capital Account.
- Unpaid liabilities: If no further information is given after transfer to Realisation Account, treat them as fully paid.
- Expense paid for a partner: Debit the benefiting partner’s Capital Account, not Realisation Account.
A positive result is profit; a negative result is loss. Share it among partners in their profit-sharing ratio.
Formula Terms
- : Realisation profit or loss.
- : Total credits in Realisation Account before transferring the result, including liabilities transferred and asset proceeds.
- : Total debits before transferring the result, including assets transferred, liabilities paid and expenses.
Order for Closing the Books
- Transfer relevant assets and external liabilities to Realisation Account.
- Record asset proceeds, liabilities paid or assumed, and realisation expenses.
- Balance Realisation Account and transfer its profit or loss to partners’ Capital Accounts in the agreed ratio.
- Transfer reserves and accumulated profits to partners’ Capital Accounts.
- Settle partner loans as required, then pay final Capital Account balances through Bank.
Illustration: Supriya and Monika
Given Information
- Profit-sharing ratio: Supriya and Monika share profits in the ratio .
- Balances: Capitals are Rs. 32,500 and Rs. 11,500; General Reserve is Rs. 13,500; creditors are Rs. 48,000.
- Opening bank balance: Cash and Bank is Rs. 40,500; this balance is not transferred to Realisation Account.
- Asset book values: Stock is Rs. 7,500; debtors are Rs. 21,500 with a Rs. 500 provision; fixed assets are Rs. 36,500.
- Realisation details: Debtors realise at a discount of ; stock realises Rs. 7,000; fixed assets realise Rs. 42,000.
- Other details: Creditors are paid in full and realisation expenses are Rs. 1,500.
Prepare the dissolution entries and determine the final amounts payable to Supriya and Monika.
- Transfer stock, debtors and fixed assets to Realisation Account at their book amounts.
- Calculate debtors’ proceeds after the discount, then add the stock and fixed-asset proceeds.
- Credit Realisation Account with creditors and the provision; debit it with creditors paid and expenses.
- Find the realisation profit and divide it in the ratio .
- Divide General Reserve in the same ratio and calculate each partner’s final Capital Account balance.
- Check that opening Bank plus asset proceeds, less payments and partners’ final balances, equals zero.
| Transaction | Debit entry | Credit entry |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer assets | Realisation A/c Rs. 65,500 | Stock A/c Rs. 7,500; Sundry Debtors A/c Rs. 21,500; Fixed Assets A/c Rs. 36,500 |
| Transfer creditors and provision | Sundry Creditors A/c Rs. 48,000; Provision for Doubtful Debts A/c Rs. 500 | Realisation A/c Rs. 48,500 |
| Record assets realised | Bank A/c Rs. 69,425 | Realisation A/c Rs. 69,425 |
| Pay creditors and realisation expenses | Realisation A/c Rs. 49,500 | Bank A/c Rs. 49,500 |
| Transfer realisation profit | Realisation A/c Rs. 2,925 | Supriya’s Capital A/c Rs. 1,755; Monika’s Capital A/c Rs. 1,170 |
| Transfer General Reserve | General Reserve A/c Rs. 13,500 | Supriya’s Capital A/c Rs. 8,100; Monika’s Capital A/c Rs. 5,400 |
| Pay final capital balances | Supriya’s Capital A/c Rs. 42,355; Monika’s Capital A/c Rs. 18,070 | Bank A/c Rs. 60,425 |
Do not transfer cash/bank to Realisation Account. In this illustration, debit Provision for Doubtful Debts and credit Realisation Account; also include the opening Bank balance when checking the final cash settlement.
Partners P and Q share profits equally. Realisation Account shows a profit of Rs. 8,000. How is it transferred?
An unrecorded asset is taken over by a partner for Rs. 6,000. Give the entry.
The firm pays Rs. 900 for a partner’s personal expense during dissolution. Which account is debited?
Quick recap
- Realisation Account records asset transfers and disposals, settlement of external liabilities, and realisation expenses.
- Cash/bank and fictitious assets are not transferred to Realisation Account; include opening cash/bank when reconciling the final settlement.
- Transfer realisation profit or loss and reserves to partners’ Capital Accounts in their profit-sharing ratio.
- In the illustration, debtors realise for Rs. 20,425 and total asset proceeds are Rs. 69,425.
- Realisation profit is Rs. 2,925; Supriya receives Rs. 42,355 and Monika receives Rs. 18,070.
- The Rs. 40,500 opening Bank balance plus receipts and less all payments leaves a nil closing balance.
Journal Entries
Realisation Account and transfer entries
- Realisation Account: It records the dissolution process and determines the profit or loss on realisation, shared by partners in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Transfer entries: Assets, other than cash, bank and fictitious assets, and external liabilities are transferred to the Realisation Account at their book values.
Sale of assets and settlement of liabilities
Creditor accepts an asset
- Full settlement: If the creditor accepts an asset in full settlement, no separate settlement entry is made after transferring the asset and liability to Realisation.
- Part settlement: If the creditor takes an asset and receives cash for the balance, record only the cash paid: Realisation Dr. → Bank Cr.
- Asset exceeds debt: If the creditor pays the firm the excess, record Bank Dr. → Realisation Cr.
- Discount on payment: Pay the actual amount; the unpaid difference contributes to Realisation profit.
Realisation expenses and partner remuneration
Special expense and remuneration cases
- Partner exceeds an agreed expense limit: Debit Realisation and credit the partner’s Capital Account for the excess paid on the firm’s behalf.
- Partner bears expenses; firm pays: Debit that partner’s Capital Account, not Realisation.
- Payer not specified: Assume expenses are paid by the partner who agreed to bear them.
- Remuneration in kind: In the specific case where a partner takes investments already transferred to Realisation towards their agreed remuneration, the source example records no entry.
Profit or loss, reserves and fictitious assets
Reserve treatment
- General Reserve: Transfer an accumulated reserve to partners’ Capital Accounts in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Workmen Compensation Reserve: If no claim is specified, distribute it to partners in their profit-sharing ratio; e.g. Rs. 15,000 equally gives Rs. 7,500 each.
- Reserve linked to an asset: A specific reserve associated with an asset may be transferred to Realisation; the Investment Fluctuation Reserve is credited to Realisation when investments are transferred.
- Specific claim or liability: Apply the relevant reserve against its related claim first; distribute any remaining balance according to the applicable treatment.
Partner loans and final settlement
Closing checks
- Order: Settle external liabilities first, then partner loans, and finally partners’ Capital Accounts.
- Debit capital: A partner must bring in cash to clear a debit balance.
- Credit capital: Pay the final credit balance from Bank.
- Check: The total paid to partners must equal the available cash and bank balance; all firm accounts should close.
Worked application: Sita, Rita and Meeta
| Case | Key treatment |
|---|---|
| Partner takes over stock or investments | Debit that partner’s Capital Account and credit Realisation at the agreed value. |
| Partner assumes a recorded liability | Debit Realisation and credit that partner’s Capital Account. |
| Unrecorded asset is sold or taken over | Debit Bank or the partner’s Capital Account; credit Realisation. |
| Bad debt written off earlier is recovered | Debit Bank and credit Realisation. |
| Outstanding unrecorded bill is paid | Debit Realisation and credit Bank. |
| Investment Fluctuation Reserve relates to investments transferred | Debit the reserve and credit Realisation. |
Do not transfer cash, bank balances or fictitious assets to Realisation. Do not treat every reserve as a partner reserve: a reserve linked to a specific asset may be credited to Realisation. Also distinguish ordinary partner takeovers from the special remuneration-in-kind case, for which the source example records no entry.
A creditor is owed Rs. 10,000, accepts equipment worth Rs. 8,000 and receives the balance in cash. What entry records the cash payment?
A partner agrees to bear dissolution expenses up to Rs. 6,000 and personally pays actual expenses of Rs. 7,600. Give the entry for the excess.
An unrecorded asset is taken over by a partner for Rs. 600. Give the journal entry.
Quick recap
- Transfer non-cash, non-fictitious assets and external liabilities to Realisation at book value.
- Record asset sales, partner takeovers and liability settlements through Realisation.
- Select expense entries based on who bears the cost and who pays; record partner remuneration separately except for the specified no-entry case.
- Transfer Realisation profit or loss and general reserves to partners in their profit-sharing ratio.
- If no Workmen Compensation claim is specified, distribute the reserve to partners in their ratio; treat asset-linked reserves separately.
- Settle partner loans and current accounts, clear debit Capital Accounts and pay final credit balances; then close all accounts.
Illustrations Based on Journal Entries
How to Close the Books on Dissolution
- Transfer assets and liabilities: Transfer applicable assets and external liabilities to the Realisation Account at book values.
- Record realisation: Record proceeds from assets, payments to settle liabilities and realisation expenses.
- Close accumulated balances: Transfer reserves and accumulated profits to partners’ capital accounts; write off fictitious assets in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Transfer result: Share the profit or loss on realisation among partners in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Settle accounts: Pay partner loans and settle partners’ capital balances through the Bank Account.
Quick recap
- Transfer recorded assets and outside liabilities to Realisation at book value.
- Record sales and takeovers at actual proceeds or agreed values; record liability settlements at amounts actually paid or assumed.
- A partner taking an asset is debited in Capital; a partner taking a liability is credited in Capital.
- Share Realisation profit or loss and accumulated reserves in the profit-sharing ratio.
- Settle partners through Bank; a partner owing the firm must contribute cash, and the Bank Account should close at nil.
Summary
Dissolution of a Firm and Dissolution of Partnership
Dissolution of a firm — The firm’s business is discontinued, its economic relations with partners end, and the firm is wound up.
Dissolution of partnership — The existing partnership relationship changes or ends, such as on admission, retirement, or death of a partner; the firm may continue.
| Point | Dissolution of a firm | Dissolution of partnership |
|---|---|---|
| Effect | Business closes; assets are realised and liabilities are paid. | Partner relationship changes or ends; the business need not close. |
| Outcome | The firm is wound up and its books are closed after settlement. | The firm may continue with a reconstituted partnership. |
| Examples | Closure of the firm. | Admission, retirement, or death of a partner. |
Settlement on Dissolution of a Firm
- Realise the firm’s assets.
- Pay creditors and settle liabilities from the realised assets.
- If the realised assets are insufficient, partners contribute the shortfall in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Settle the partners’ accounts and make final payments due to them.
- Close the Cash/Bank account and the firm’s books.
Realisation Account
Realisation Account — An account prepared on dissolution to record the sale and realisation of assets and the settlement of creditors and liabilities.
Purpose and settlement
- Records Transactions arising from asset realisation and settlement of creditors.
- Result Any profit or loss on realisation is shared among partners in their profit-sharing ratio.
- Completion Partners’ accounts are settled and the Cash/Bank account is closed.
What is the purpose of the Realisation Account?
Quick recap
- Dissolution of a firm closes the business and ends the partners’ economic relations with it.
- Dissolution of partnership can occur without closing the firm.
- On firm dissolution, assets are realised and creditors are paid first.
- Partners contribute in their profit-sharing ratio if realisations do not cover liabilities.
- The Realisation Account records asset realisations and creditor settlements.
- Realisation profit or loss is shared in the partners’ profit-sharing ratio; then partners’ accounts and the Cash/Bank account are settled.
Formula sheet
Accountancy — ALL CHAPTERS
1
Accounting for Share Capital
2
Issue and Redemption of Debentures
3
Financial Statements of a Company
4
Analysis of Financial Statements
5
Accounting Ratios
6
Cash Flow Statement
1
Overview Of Computerised Accounting System
2
Spreadsheet
3
Use Of Spreadsheet In Business Applications
4
Graphs And Charts For Business Data
1
Accounting for Partnership: Basic Concepts
2
Reconstitution of a Partnership Firm –Admission of a Partner
3
Reconstitution of a Partnership Firm –Retirement/Death of a Partner
4
Dissolution of Partnership Firm