Class 12 Humanities . English . Kaleidoscope . The Argumentative Indian
Chapter 18: The Argumentative Indian
Ch 18
English
Class 12 Humanities
Indian Intellectual Tradition
Amartya Sen
- Born in 1933; awarded the 1998 Nobel Prize in Economics for his contribution to welfare economics.
- He is Lamont Professor at Harvard.
- The essay is from his 2005 book The Argumentative Indian, subtitled Writings on Indian Culture, History and Identity.
India’s Tradition of Debate
A Long Tradition of Argument
- Sen presents discussion, questioning and debate as a longstanding feature of Indian intellectual life.
- India’s fondness for extended speech is illustrated by V. K. Krishna Menon’s nine-hour UN speech on 23 January 1957, defending India’s position on Kashmir.
- Menon led the Indian delegation to the UN and served as India’s Defence Minister from 1957 to 1962.
- The Ramayana and Mahabharata are far longer than Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey; the Mahabharata alone is about seven times as long as both epics combined.
- The Indian epics weave many stories around their central tales and are rich in dialogue, dilemmas, debates and opposing arguments.
The Krishna–Arjuna Debate
Two Moral Positions in the Bhagavad Gita
- On the eve of battle between the Pandavas and the Kauravas, Arjuna doubts whether a just cause can justify the suffering and deaths—including those of his kin—that war will bring.
- Krishna, a divine incarnation and Arjuna’s charioteer, insists that Arjuna must fulfil his duty as a warrior and fight for the just cause, regardless of consequences.
- Krishna’s position prioritises duty; Arjuna’s consequential perspective asks whether the results of action will bring good or harm.
- Krishna’s argument prevails in the religious reading of the Gita, which became a major theological text in Hindu philosophy and focuses on removing Arjuna’s doubts.
| Point | Krishna | Arjuna |
|---|---|---|
| Moral focus | Doing one’s duty | Considering consequences |
| View of battle | Fight for a just cause, whatever the outcome | Question the suffering and deaths the battle will cause |
| Sen’s emphasis | Duty matters | Consequences must also be considered |
Why the Debate Remains Open
- Krishna’s position was admired by Christopher Isherwood, who translated the Gita into English, and by T. S. Eliot; Wilhelm von Humboldt praised the Gita in the early nineteenth century.
- Eliot summarises Krishna’s advice as “Not fare well / But fare forward”: keep acting according to duty rather than focusing on outcomes.
- Sen argues that the Mahabharata gives both positions careful treatment; the desolation of the post-war Indo-Gangetic plain strengthens the force of Arjuna’s doubts.
- Thus, the case for “faring well”—judging actions by their consequences—is not erased by the Gita’s emphasis on duty.
The Debate’s Modern Relevance
Oppenheimer and the Nuclear Bomb
- On 16 July 1945, J. Robert Oppenheimer quoted Krishna’s words, “I am become death, the destroyer of worlds,” while watching the first nuclear explosion.
- Oppenheimer could view developing the bomb as duty to the side he considered just, much as Krishna urges Arjuna to act for a just cause.
- Later, Oppenheimer criticised the impulse to pursue technically successful work first and consider its consequences only afterward.
- Sen links their dilemmas: commitment to duty or a cause must be weighed against the human cost of one’s actions.
Duty and Consequences
Sen argues that acting from duty matters, but people must also consider the harm their actions may cause. The Mahabharata’s wider debate complements the Gita’s focus on duty.
Applying the Argument Today
- The debate applies to global problems such as terrorism, war, violence, epidemics, insecurity and poverty.
- For India, Sen highlights economic development, nuclear confrontation and regional peace as concerns requiring both duty-based and consequence-based reasoning.
- He argues that the Gita’s single-minded message of duty should be supplemented by the Mahabharata’s broader argumentative wisdom.
What is the difference between “faring forward” and “faring well”?
How does Sen connect Arjuna’s dilemma with Oppenheimer’s response to the 1945 nuclear explosion?
Quick recap
- Sen presents debate and questioning as a longstanding part of Indian intellectual life.
- The Mahabharata is about seven times as long as the Iliad and the Odyssey combined.
- Krishna stresses duty; Arjuna stresses the consequences of action.
- The Mahabharata preserves the force of both positions, even when the Gita favours Krishna’s view.
- Oppenheimer’s reflections connect the ancient moral debate to modern technology and warfare.
- Sen argues that duty should be considered alongside consequences in addressing present-day problems.
Gender, Caste And Voice
Women in Public and Intellectual Life
Gender and political participation
- Unequal voice: Men have generally dominated debate, but women’s participation in Indian political and intellectual life has been significant.
- Political leadership: Women have led major national and regional political parties, and many women held important positions in the independence movement.
- Independence comparison: The Congress-led movement included more women in important positions than the Russian and Chinese revolutionary movements combined.
- Congress milestones: Sarojini Naidu became the first woman President of the Indian National Congress in 1925; Nellie Sengupta became the second in 1933.
- Comparison: Naidu’s election came 50 years before Margaret Thatcher became leader of a major British political party in 1975.
- Presidential influence: The Congress President held real authority; Subhas Chandra Bose’s elections in 1938 and 1939 led to a major conflict with Gandhi. In 2004, Sonia Gandhi remained Congress President rather than becoming Prime Minister.
Women in ancient and epic debates
- Ancient debates: The Upanishads, composed from about the eighth century BCE, preserve important philosophical dialogues involving women.
- Gargi: In the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, the scholar Gargi challenges Yajnavalkya with sharp questions, comparing her approach to a warrior advancing with arrows.
- Maitreyi: She asks whether owning all the earth’s wealth could bring immortality; Yajnavalkya replies that wealth cannot provide it.
- Development insight: Maitreyi’s question highlights that income and commodities do not automatically give people the capability or freedom to live well; development must focus on people’s lives, not wealth alone.
- Draupadi: In the Mahabharata, she urges the reluctant Yudhishthira to fight the usurpers with appropriate anger. Bharavi’s sixth-century Kiratarjuniya presents her forceful argument.
- Women’s range: These examples challenge the stereotype that women’s arguments are always tender or peace-loving. Rani of Jhansi also represents women’s leadership in armed resistance against British rule in the mid-nineteenth century.
Gargi
- A confident woman scholar who questions Yajnavalkya in a public philosophical debate.
- Her probing questions demonstrate women’s intellectual presence and authority in ancient India.
Maitreyi
- A thoughtful questioner who asks whether wealth can secure immortality.
- Her question also draws attention to the gap between economic resources and the freedom to live well.
Draupadi
- A forceful speaker who challenges Yudhishthira’s reluctance to fight.
- She argues against passive forbearance and urges action to reclaim the kingdom.
Caste, Class and Religious Orthodoxy
Challenges to caste hierarchy
- Class and orthodoxy: Merchants, craftsmen and others challenged Brahminical authority. Some were affluent, yet remained disadvantaged within a priest-dominated order.
- Buddhism and Jainism: These initially rebellious movements questioned priestly superiority and promoted human equality; early Buddhist and Jain texts contain arguments of protest and resistance.
- Epic debates: Classical texts preserve opposition to caste hierarchy, showing that challenges to inequality existed alongside caste arrangements.
- Bhrigu and Bharadvaja: Bhrigu links caste divisions to physical traits such as skin colour. Bharadvaja counters that skin colour varies within every caste, so this cannot define caste.
- Shared human experience: Bharadvaja asks how caste differences can be justified when everyone experiences desire, anger, fear, sorrow, worry, hunger and labour.
- Bhavisya Purana: Its genealogical argument says that all four castes are children of God and therefore belong to the same caste; all human beings have the same father.
Medieval poets and social equality
- Mystical movements: By the fifteenth century, medieval poets influenced by Hindu Bhakti and Muslim Sufi egalitarianism rejected social and religious barriers.
- Working-class voices: Kabir was a weaver, Dadu a cotton-carder, Ravi-das a shoemaker and Sena a barber.
- Women poets: Mira Bai, Andal, Daya-bai, Sahajo-bai and Ksema were among the women associated with these movements.
- Shared challenge: These poets questioned caste and class divisions as well as barriers between religions, showing that influential arguments came from socially humble communities.
The Argumentative Tradition Today
Voice and contemporary inequality
- Inclusive tradition: Indian argument has crossed barriers of gender, caste, class and community; it is not solely the preserve of men or elites.
- Use today: Argument can help resist contemporary inequalities and make the claims of disadvantaged groups heard.
- Source of force: Powerful arguments need not rely on elite education or polished dialectical training; their strength can come from the substance of people’s claims and experiences.
Voice across social divisions
Women and disadvantaged groups have taken part in India’s argumentative tradition. Their challenges to authority show how debate can question inequality and support a more inclusive society.
How does Sen connect Maitreyi’s question about wealth and immortality with economic development?
Give examples showing that Indian argument crossed barriers of gender, caste, class and community.
Quick recap
- Women such as Gargi, Maitreyi and Draupadi played important roles in ancient Indian debates.
- Sarojini Naidu became Congress President in 1925, followed by Nellie Sengupta in 1933.
- Maitreyi’s question shows that wealth alone cannot ensure meaningful achievement or freedom.
- Buddhism and Jainism questioned priestly superiority and advanced ideas of equality.
- Bharadvaja challenged caste distinctions by pointing to variation in skin colour and shared human experiences.
- Bhakti-Sufi poets, including working-class voices and women, challenged social and religious barriers.
- Argument can help disadvantaged groups question inequality; it is not only an elite skill.
Democracy And Debate
Democracy as Public Reasoning
- Argument and society: India’s long tradition of debate has shaped its social and cultural life, making intellectual diversity and disagreement familiar.
- Public life: Persistent argument influences Indian politics and supports the development of democracy and its secular priorities.
Historical Roots of Indian Democracy
- Public reasoning and democracy: Across the world, traditions of public discussion and reasoning are closely connected to democracy.
- India’s contribution: India’s long history of debate and tolerance of differing ideas helped make democracy easier to establish and sustain.
- Combined influences: At independence, India drew both on democratic institutions developed in Europe and America—especially Great Britain—and on its own tradition of public reasoning.
- Significance: India became the first country outside the Western world to adopt a resolutely democratic constitution.
Avoiding Two Misconceptions
- Not simply a Western gift: Indian democracy should not be explained only as an outcome of British influence.
- Not uniquely suited: India should not be treated as having a history that makes it uniquely or naturally suited to democracy.
- Central idea: Democracy is strengthened wherever traditions of public discussion and interactive reasoning can be drawn upon.
Debate as a Foundation of Democracy
Democracy depends on public discussion and the exchange of reasons. India’s own argumentative tradition, alongside international democratic influences, helped shape its democratic path.
How did India’s tradition of public reasoning contribute to democracy?
What two misconceptions about Indian democracy does the author caution against?
Quick recap
- India’s tradition of argument has shaped its culture, politics and public life.
- Debate and tolerance of differing ideas support democracy and secular priorities.
- Democracy is closely connected to public discussion and interactive reasoning.
- India drew on both international democratic institutions and its own argumentative traditions.
- Do not view Indian democracy as only a Western gift or India as uniquely suited to it.
- Public reasoning can help democracy take root and remain strong across societies.
Exercise
The Essay: Key Point in the Exercise
- Krishna and Arjuna: Sen values both the duty to act and the need to consider consequences.
- Indian tradition: The essay examines how debate crossed gender, caste and class barriers and shaped public life.
- Democracy: Sen links India’s democratic tradition to public discussion and reasoning, not merely to Western influence.
Argumentative Writing and Qualification
- Evidence: Argumentative writing supports its claims with relevant examples and facts from the essay.
- Qualification: Sen often qualifies claims to acknowledge complexity rather than present them as absolute.
Noun Phrases
| Example | Feature |
|---|---|
| “The second woman head of the Indian National Congress, Nellie Sengupta, was elected in 1933.” | “Nellie Sengupta” is in apposition to the noun phrase identifying the person. |
| “This concerns the relation—and the distance—between income and achievement.” | The dashes mark parenthetical information; “between income and achievement” is a prepositional phrase. |
| “the class basis of the rapid spread of Buddhism, in particular, in India” | The noun “basis” is expanded by prepositional phrases; “in particular, in India” adds a further qualification. |
What does the exercise’s quoted comment say about Arjuna’s arguments?
What is apposition in a noun phrase?
Quick recap
- The quoted comment preserves Arjuna’s case for “faring well”, alongside “faring forward”.
- Argumentative writing supports statements with textual evidence.
- Qualifiers such as “often enough” limit or soften a claim.
- Noun phrases can be expanded before or after their main noun.
- Apposition identifies or renames a noun; parenthetical information adds an aside.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood