Class 12 Humanities . English . Kaleidoscope . Why the Novel Matters
Chapter 17: Why The Novel Matters
Ch 17
English
Class 12 Humanities
Importance Of Novels
D. H. Lawrence
- Born in 1885 in a coal-mining town; died in 1930. His father was a miner and his mother was a teacher.
- His wife was German, and they lived in several countries, including Italy, Germany, Australia, Tahiti and Mexico.
- His writing opposed puritanism, mediocrity and the dehumanising effects of industrial society.
The living body
- Lawrence challenges the idea that a person is a body containing a separate, superior soul, mind or spirit.
- The hand is not a lifeless tool: it senses, learns, acts and shares in the person’s life just as the brain does.
- The living self extends to the fingertips; a pen, by contrast, is an inanimate object.
- The body is not merely a container like a bottle or clay vessel. Every living part—skin, veins, bones and blood—belongs to the whole living person.
What the novelist understands
- A novelist recognises life as something experienced through the whole living person, rather than as an abstract soul or spirit separate from the body.
- The body has direct, intense knowledge: touching fire teaches that it burns more vividly than an abstract theory can.
- Messages and ideas are not alive in themselves; they can affect a person when that living person receives and responds to them.
- Lawrence argues that knowledge grows from the experiences of living people, not from disembodied ideas alone.
Life above abstractions
- Lawrence places living beings above dead things: even a cabbage in the rain is wonderfully alive.
- He says a live dog is better than a dead lion, but a live lion is better than a live dog—emphasising life while recognising distinctions among living beings.
- He criticises saints who treat themselves as spiritual nourishment, philosophers who make thought supreme, and scientists who reduce a person to body parts or tissues.
- A person is not just a soul, body, mind, brain or set of organs. The living whole is greater than any one of its parts.
The value of embodied life
The essay argues that life is experienced through the whole living person. Novels matter because they can reveal this vivid, bodily reality instead of reducing people to abstractions or separate parts.
What distinguishes animate things from inanimate things in Lawrence’s argument?
What simple truth do philosophers and scientists often overlook?
Why does Lawrence value the novel?
Quick recap
- Lawrence rejects the separation of a superior mind or soul from the living body.
- The hand and other bodily parts are alive and participate in sensing and knowing.
- A living person’s direct experience is more vital than abstract ideas about life.
- Lawrence criticises religious, philosophical and scientific views that diminish living experience.
- He contrasts a live dog with a dead lion, then says a live lion is better than a live dog.
- The whole living person is greater than any one part or label; novels can portray life in its embodied fullness.
Living Through Novels
The Novel and the Whole Person
- The novelist’s claim: Saints, scientists, philosophers and poets may illuminate particular aspects of human life; the novel can bring the whole person to life.
- A living book: Books are not life itself, but a novel can affect us deeply and make the whole person “tremble” with life.
- Partial influences: Plato, the Sermon on the Mount and the Ten Commandments stir different parts of a person, but do not necessarily engage the whole self.
Whole Novels and Human Change
- Whole-person effect: A complete novel can communicate with the whole person, rather than developing only one quality or direction.
- Examples: Lawrence calls the Bible, Homer and Shakespeare supreme old novels because they can mean many things to many people.
- Against narrow growth: A single direction can become a dead end; life needs the full, varied growth of the “whole tree.”
Change, Not Fixed Absolutes
- No permanent formula: Lawrence rejects absolute rules and fixed truths that claim to apply unchanged in every situation.
- Renewal: Nature changes and renews itself; human-made words and doctrines can grow stale when treated as unchanging absolutes.
- Life in motion: People and relationships keep changing. This continual change can sustain love and prevent life from becoming inert.
Integrity Without a Fixed Identity
- Changing self: A person can remain whole while their thoughts, feelings and actions change over time.
- False certainty: Defining oneself too rigidly turns a living person into a fixed pattern and limits genuine individuality.
- Integrity: It is not a permanent label or carefully constructed ego; it belongs to the living, changing whole person.
Characters Must Be Alive
- Living characters: Novel characters must feel real and change; if they act only according to a fixed pattern of goodness or wickedness, the story loses life.
- Lesson for people: Like characters, people must live as whole, responsive beings rather than merely follow a prescribed idea of what life should be.
The Novel as a Guide to Living
- Many ideas of life: People pursue very different goals, from spiritual seeking and wealth to reform, pleasure or power; these aims can even contradict one another.
- Beyond commandments: Fixed “thou shalt not” rules cannot guide every changing situation. The novel helps readers recognise when someone is truly alive or merely going through the motions.
- Instinct for life: By showing people becoming emotionally or spiritually inert, novels can develop our sense of living more fully.
Life Beyond Simple Moral Labels
- Context matters: What is right in one situation may be wrong in another; goodness or wickedness can also make a person lifeless when followed as a rigid pattern.
- Whole-consciousness instinct: Sound moral judgement involves the whole person—bodily, mental and spiritual—not merely a fixed rule.
- Purpose of the novel: When life is valued above mere safety, the novel can give full play to human experience and reveal the wholeness of people.
The Novel Reveals Whole Human Life
A novel can engage the many parts of a person at once, helping readers understand human beings beyond one quality, rule or moral label.
Change and Individuality
Human identity is dynamic. Integrity does not require behaving consistently with a fixed self-image; it can exist through continual change.
Life Beyond Fixed Morality
Lawrence values a responsive instinct for life over rigid rules, arguing that moral choices depend on the whole person and the particular situation.
- Tremulation
- A trembling or vibration; Lawrence’s image for the effect a book has on a reader.
- Cul-de-sac
- A dead end; a course that leads nowhere further.
- Inertia
- Resistance to change or movement.
- Ego
- A person’s idea or image of themselves.
- Simulacrum
- A lifeless imitation or appearance of something.
- Masticating
- Chewing.
- Co-respondent
- A person named alongside a spouse in a divorce case, traditionally in connection with adultery.
How does Lawrence reconcile inconsistency of behaviour with integrity?
Why does Lawrence consider the novel a guide to life?
Quick recap
- The novel can affect the whole person, while other forms may engage only particular aspects.
- Lawrence values change and rejects fixed absolutes and narrow patterns of growth.
- Integrity belongs to a changing, complex self—not a rigid self-definition.
- Novel characters must live beyond prescribed patterns of goodness or wickedness.
- Novels help readers recognise life and lifelessness, developing an instinct for living fully.
- Moral judgement should respond to the whole person and the circumstances.
Exercise
Verb Classes and Sentence Structure
Basic sentence structure
- Sentence: A sentence consists of a noun phrase and a verb phrase; the verb phrase is built around a verb.
- Noun phrase: Names or identifies the subject; the verb phrase says what the subject does or is.
Intransitive verb — A verb that does not take a direct object; it may be followed by a complement that adds information, often in a prepositional phrase.
Copula (linking verb) — A verb that links its subject to a complement describing or identifying that subject; common copulas include be, become and seem.
| Example | Verb class | Complement |
|---|---|---|
| The grass withers. / The flower fades. / The bud opens. | Intransitive | No direct object or subject complement |
| The chameleon creeps from a brown rock onto a green leaf. | Intransitive | The following prepositional phrases function as complements, giving adverbial information |
| The Word shall stand forever. | Intransitive | “Forever” adds adverbial information as a complement |
| My hand is alive. / Nothing is important. | Copula: be | Adjective or adjective phrase |
| You are a novelist. / The novel is the book of life. | Copula: be | Noun phrase |
| It seems important. / The Word becomes more and more boring. | Copulas: seem, become | Adjective or adjective phrase |
Recognising the verb and its complement
- Noun-phrase complements: “I am a thief and a murderer,” “Right and wrong is an instinct,” “I am a very curious assembly of incongruous parts,” “It is a funny sort of superstition” and “You’re a philosopher.”
- Adjective-phrase complements: “Nothing is important,” “The whole is greater than the part” and “I am greater than anything that is merely a part of me.”
- Combined complements: “I am a man, and alive” has a noun phrase (“a man”) and an adjective (“alive”) describing the subject.
- Intransitive verbs: “The flower fades” and “The bud opens” have no direct object; in “The Word shall stand forever,” “forever” gives adverbial information.
Pronunciation: “ch” and “gh”
| Sound | Examples | Useful pattern |
|---|---|---|
| /k/ | character, chorus, chord, chlorine | Often occurs in words of Greek or Latin origin; “ch” before another consonant is pronounced /k/ in examples such as chlorine and Christian. |
| /tʃ/ | church, chart, chin, catch | The most common pronunciation in many English words. |
| /ʃ/ | champagne, chef, machine, cache | Often occurs in words of French origin. |
| Silent or /k/ | schism (silent “ch”); schizophrenia (/k/) | Pronunciation varies in words beginning with “sch.” |
| Position or sound | Examples |
|---|---|
| At the beginning: /g/ | ghost, ghoul, ghat |
| In the middle or at the end: /f/ | cough, rough, tough |
| In the middle or at the end: silent | taught, plough, drought |
How do intransitive verbs differ from copulas?
What are the main pronunciations of “ch” and “gh”?
Quick recap
- A sentence consists of a noun phrase and a verb phrase built around a verb.
- Intransitive verbs take no direct object; following phrases can function as complements and provide adverbial information.
- Copulas such as be, become and seem link a subject to a noun-phrase or adjective-phrase complement.
- The spelling “ch” can represent /k/, /tʃ/ or /ʃ/; its pronunciation often reflects word origin.
- Initial “gh” is pronounced /g/; medial or final “gh” may be pronounced /f/ or be silent.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
The Last Lesson
2
Lost Spring (Stories of Stolen Childhood)
3
Deep Water
4
The Rattrap
5
Indigo
6
Poets and Pancakes
7
The Interview (From the Introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews edited by Christopher Silvester).
8
Going Places
9
My Mother at Sixty-six
10
Keeping Quiet
11
A Thing of Beauty
12
A Roadside Stand
13
Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers
1
I Sell My Dreams
2
Eveline
3
A Wedding In Brownsville
4
Tomorrow
5
One Centimetre
6
A Lecture Upon The Shadow
7
Poems By Milton
8
Poems By Blake
9
Kubla Khan OR A Vision In A Dream: A Fragment
10
Trees
11
The Wild Swans At Coole
12
Time And Time Again
13
Blood
14
Freedom
15
The Mark On The Wall
16
Film-making
17
Why The Novel Matters
18
The Argumentative Indian
19
On Science Fiction
20
Chandalika
21
Broken Images
1
The Third Level
2
The Tiger King
3
Journey to the end of the Earth
4
The Enemy
5
On The Face Of It
6
Memories of Childhood