Class 10 . English . Footprints Without Feet . A Question of Trust

Chapter 4: A Question of Trust

Ch 4

English

Class 10

Lecture 1

The Unlikely Criminal with a Passion for Books

Reference video · Lecture 1The Unlikely Criminal with a Passion for Books

The Story’s Opening Question

  • Two sayings: The story opens by contrasting “set a thief to catch a thief” with “there is honour among thieves.”
  • Framing: The events invite readers to consider which saying the story illustrates.

Horace Danby’s Secret

  • Public image: About fifty, unmarried, and a successful maker of locks, Horace is considered a respectable citizen.
  • Secret life: He is not completely honest; fifteen years earlier, he served his first and only prison sentence.
  • Motivation: Horace loves rare, expensive books and steals from a safe once a year to fund his collection.
  • Method: He plans each theft carefully and secretly buys books through an agent.

The Plan at Shotover Grange

  • Preparation: Horace studies the house’s rooms, wiring, paths, and garden for two weeks.
  • Target: The safe holds jewels worth about £15,000; Horace expects to raise at least £5,000 by selling them.
  • Timing: With the family in London, the two servants leave for the movies, giving Horace about four hours.
  • Entry: Wearing gloves, he uses the kitchen key left outside and quiets the friendly dog, Sherry, by calling it by name.

The Unexpected Interruption

  • Safe location: Horace finds the safe behind a painting, as described in a magazine article about the house.
  • Obstacle: The flowers worsen his hay fever, making him sneeze while he prepares to open the safe.
  • Interruption: A voice speaks from the doorway and asks whether he has a cold or hay fever; Horace answers honestly before he can think.
  • Risk: The speaker says they heard him from upstairs and advises him to see a doctor if he is serious about his work.

Horace Danby

  • Skilled and methodical: His experience making locks and his careful planning help him prepare the burglary.
  • Respectable in appearance: He runs a successful business and is regarded as honest.
  • Motivated by books: He steals to fund his passion for rare books.
  • Careful, yet vulnerable: He wears gloves and studies the house, but hay fever and an unexpected voice disrupt his plan.
Theme

Respectability and Hidden Crime

Horace appears to be a good citizen, yet secretly commits theft each year. The contrast shows that outward respectability does not always reveal a person’s true actions.

Word meanings
respectable
Considered honest and worthy of respect.
hay fever
An allergy that can cause sneezing, often triggered by pollen.
safe
A strong locked box used to protect valuables.
burglar alarm
A system designed to warn of unauthorised entry.
hindering
Making an activity difficult or slowing it down.
agent
A person who acts for someone else, such as by buying things on their behalf.

What does Horace Danby like to collect, and why does he steal every year?

Answer: He loves rare, expensive books. He steals once a year to get enough money to buy them.

How does Horace prepare for the burglary at Shotover Grange?

Answer: He studies the house for two weeks, waits until the servants leave, wears gloves, and brings tools to open the safe.

What interrupts Horace as he prepares to open the safe?

Answer: His hay fever makes him sneeze, and an unexpected voice suddenly speaks to him from the doorway.

Quick recap

  • The story opens with two sayings about thieves: “set a thief to catch a thief” and “there is honour among thieves.”
  • Horace Danby is a successful locksmith with a hidden life as a yearly burglar.
  • He steals to buy rare and expensive books, which he purchases through an agent.
  • He served his first and only prison sentence fifteen years before the events at Shotover Grange.
  • The jewels are worth about £15,000, and Horace hopes to raise at least £5,000.
  • Hay fever and an unexpected voice interrupt his carefully planned attempt to open the safe.
Lecture 2

The Intruder and the Homeowner

Reference video · Lecture 2The Intruder and the Homeowner

The Intruder Meets the Woman

  • Horace Danby is caught inside Shotover Grange by a confident young woman dressed in red, who speaks as if she owns the house.
  • She threatens to call the police. Horace admits he is afraid of prison and asks her to let him go.
  • The woman claims she left her jewels in the safe and needs them for a party, but has forgotten the combination.
  • Horace agrees to open the safe in return for his freedom, believing her story.
Horace Danby encounters the woman in the house he is robbing.
Horace Danby encounters the woman in the house he is robbing.

The Theft and Horace’s Arrest

  • Horace opens the safe without gloves and gives the jewels to the woman; he leaves happily, thinking he has helped her.
  • After keeping his promise for two days, he thinks of the books he wants and plans another robbery.
  • On the third day, police arrest Horace for the jewel robbery at Shotover Grange. His fingerprints are throughout the room.
  • The real homeowner—a sharp-tongued, grey-haired woman of sixty—calls Horace’s story nonsense.

The Outcome

  • Horace is sent to prison and becomes an assistant librarian.
  • He realises that the charming young woman was also a thief and had tricked him.
  • Horace becomes angry when people speak of “honour among thieves,” because he was deceived by a fellow criminal.

Horace Danby

  • A skilled, habitual burglar; he says he steals only from people with a lot of money.
  • He is afraid of prison and is persuaded by the woman’s convincing story.
  • Careless: he removes his gloves before opening the safe, leaving fingerprints.

The young woman

  • Charming, confident and quick-thinking; she acts like the homeowner.
  • A clever thief who manipulates Horace into opening the safe and taking the blame.
Theme

Deception and misplaced trust

Horace trusts the woman because she appears respectable and offers him freedom. Her deception turns his own criminal methods against him.

Who is speaking to Horace Danby?

Answer: A clever young woman pretending to be the homeowner; she is actually a thief.

Who is the real culprit in the jewel robbery?

Answer: The young woman who deceives Horace is the real culprit. Horace is arrested because his fingerprints are left at the scene.

Quick recap

  • A young woman tricks Horace into opening the safe by pretending to be its owner.
  • Horace leaves fingerprints because he opens the safe without gloves.
  • The real homeowner calls Horace’s story nonsense, and he is arrested for the jewel robbery.
  • The young woman is revealed as a thief who has outwitted another thief.
  • The story highlights deception and the danger of misplaced trust.
Lecture 3

Glossary

Reference video · Lecture 3Glossary
Word meanings
Hay fever
A disorder affecting the nose and throat, caused by an allergy to pollen or dust.

Quick recap

  • Hay fever is a disorder.
  • It affects the nose and throat.
  • It is caused by an allergy.
  • Pollen or dust can trigger the allergy.

English — ALL CHAPTERS

1

A Letter To God

View

2

Nelson Mandela Long Walk To Freedom

View

3

Two Stories About Flying

View

4

From The Diary Of Anne Frank

View

5

Glimpses Of India

View

6

Mijbil The Otter: Gavin Maxwell

View

7

Madam Rides The Bus

View

8

The Sermons At Benares

View

9

The Proposal

View

1

A Triumph of Surgery

View

2

The Thief’s Story

View

3

The Midnight Visitor

View

4

A Question of Trust

View

5

Footprints without Feet

View

6

The Making of a Scientist

View

7

The Necklace

View

8

Bholi

View

9

The Book That Saved the Earth

View