Class 10 . English . First Flight . The Sermons At Benares
Chapter 8: The Sermons At Benares
Ch 8
English
Class 10
Gautama Buddha And Kisa Gotami
Gautama Buddha’s Early Life and Search
- Siddhartha Gautama: Born a prince in northern India in 563 B.C.; his dates are given as 563 B.C.–483 B.C.
- Early life: He studied Hindu sacred scriptures from the age of twelve, married four years later, and had a son.
- Turning point: At about twenty-five, seeing a sick man, an old man, a funeral procession and a monk moved him to seek answers to human suffering.
- Search for enlightenment: He wandered for seven years, then meditated beneath a peepal tree and attained enlightenment after seven days.
- Buddha: He called the tree the Bodhi Tree, meaning “Tree of Wisdom,” and became known as the Buddha, “the Awakened” or “the Enlightened.”
- Teaching: He began teaching and preached his first sermon at Benares, a holy bathing place on the River Ganges.
Kisa Gotami’s Search for a Cure
- Her grief: After her only son died, Kisa Gotami carried him to her neighbours, asking for medicine.
- The Buddha’s request: The Buddha asked her to bring mustard seeds from a house where no child, husband, parent or friend had died.
- Her discovery: Each family she visited had lost a loved one; no house could provide seeds that met the condition.
- Her realisation: Watching city lights appear and go out, she understood that human lives also end and that death is common to all.
- Change in outlook: She recognised that her grief was not unique and that clinging to personal sorrow could not alter death.
The Buddha’s Teaching on Death and Grief
- Life is fragile: Everyone who is born must die; youth, age, wisdom or status cannot prevent death.
- Images of impermanence: Ripe fruits may fall, and every earthen pot eventually breaks—just as mortal lives come to an end.
- Death is universal: Relatives cannot save those who are dying; all living beings are subject to death and decay.
- Grief cannot restore the dead: Weeping and lamentation do not bring the dead back and may deepen the mourner’s pain.
- Path to peace: Drawing out the “arrow” of lamentation, complaint and grief—letting go of them—leads towards peace of mind.
| Image | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Mustard seeds | The condition reveals that every family has experienced death. |
| Flickering city lights | Human lives appear and go out, just as the lights do. |
| The arrow of grief | Lamentation causes pain; letting it go helps a person seek peace. |
Kisa Gotami
- Grief-stricken: She desperately seeks a cure after her only son’s death.
- Persistent: She visits many homes to fulfil the Buddha’s request.
- Changed by experience: Discovering that every household has known death helps her understand that loss is universal.
The Buddha
- Wise: He understands the universal nature of life, death and suffering.
- Compassionate and skilful: Rather than merely explaining death, he guides Kisa Gotami to discover its universality for herself.
Acceptance of Death
Death is universal and unavoidable. Accepting this truth, rather than clinging to personal grief, helps a person move towards peace.
- Enlightenment
- A state of deep spiritual understanding.
- Sermon
- A religious or moral talk.
- Dipping places
- Bathing places.
- Inscrutable
- Difficult or impossible to understand.
- Procure
- To obtain or get something.
- Valley of desolation
- An area filled with deep sorrow.
- Mortal
- A living being that is bound to die.
- Afflicted with
- Affected by pain, suffering or trouble.
- Lamentation
- An expression of sorrow.
- Composed
- Calm and in control of one’s feelings.
- Subject to
- Liable to experience or be affected by something.
- Chanced upon
- Came across by chance.
Why did the Buddha ask Kisa Gotami to bring mustard seeds from a house untouched by death?
What did Kisa Gotami understand as she watched the city lights?
According to the Buddha, why can lamentation not bring peace?
Quick recap
- Siddhartha Gautama (563 B.C.–483 B.C.) became the Buddha after seeking enlightenment about human suffering.
- Enlightenment timeline: After seven years of wandering, he attained enlightenment after seven days beneath a peepal tree, later called the Bodhi Tree or Tree of Wisdom.
- Kisa Gotami learned through her search for mustard seeds that every household has experienced death.
- Death is unavoidable: All living beings, regardless of age or status, are subject to it.
- Grief cannot reverse death; acceptance and release from lamentation lead towards peace of mind.
For Anne Gregory (Poem)
William Butler Yeats
- Irish nationalist poet who lived from 1865 to 1939.
- He was educated in London and Dublin.
- He was interested in folklore and mythology.
- He won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1923.
For Anne Gregory
- The speaker says young men are captivated by Anne’s golden-yellow hair.
- He doubts they can love her for her inner self rather than her attractive hair.
- Anne argues that she can dye her hair a different colour.
- She hopes this will show whether young men love her as a person, not for her appearance.
- The speaker recalls a religious man’s claim that only God can love someone entirely for themselves.
- The ending questions whether human love can be free from attraction to outward beauty.
What the poem is about
- A young man and Anne Gregory debate whether people love her for herself or because of her beautiful yellow hair.
- Anne suggests changing her hair colour; the young man replies that only God can love her wholly for herself.
| Device | Example | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Metaphor | “Ramparts” for the hair around Anne’s ear | Presents her hair as a striking feature that captures attention. |
| Imagery | “honey-coloured” and “yellow hair” | Creates a vivid picture of Anne’s distinctive hair. |
| Dialogue | The young man and Anne speak in turn | Makes the debate about beauty and genuine love feel immediate. |
| Repetition | “for yourself alone” and “not your yellow hair” | Emphasises the difference between loving a person and being attracted to appearance. |
Appearance and genuine love
The poem contrasts attraction to physical beauty with love for a person’s inner self. It suggests that human affection may be influenced by appearance, while perfect unconditional love belongs to God.
- Ramparts
- High, thick defensive walls around a fort or castle.
- Honey-coloured
- Golden-yellow or amber in colour.
- Despair
- A state of hopelessness or deep distress.
- Yesternight
- Last night.
- Declare
- To state or announce clearly.
- Text
- A written passage, here referring to a religious passage.
What do “great honey-coloured / Ramparts at your ear” refer to?
Why does Anne say she can dye her hair?
Quick recap
- Anne Gregory’s yellow hair attracts the young men around her.
- The young man doubts they can love her independently of her beauty.
- Anne proposes dyeing her hair to test whether they value her inner self.
- The poem ends with the claim that only God can love someone wholly for themselves.
- Its central contrast is between physical attraction and unconditional love.
Exercise
Kisa Gotami and the Buddha’s Teaching
| Stage | What she asks or discovers | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| First search | She asks the Buddha for medicine to bring her dead son back to life. He tells her to get mustard seeds from a home untouched by death. | She finds no such home; every family has lost someone. |
| Second search | She again goes from house to house, asking whether anyone in each family has died. | People offer mustard seeds, but no household is free of death. She understands that loss is shared by all. |
What Kisa Gotami Learns
- Realisation: Death is universal and unavoidable; no family is untouched by it.
- Selfish grief: Her sorrow had made her see only her own loss, not the grief experienced by others.
- Buddha’s purpose: He helps her discover the truth through experience, guiding her towards understanding and acceptance.
What does Kisa Gotami understand on her second search, and how does the Buddha help her understand it?
Language: Older Expressions and Semicolons
| Older expression | Current meaning |
|---|---|
| give thee medicine for thy child | Give you medicine for your child. |
| Pray tell me | Please tell me. |
| Kisa repaired to the Buddha | Kisa went to the Buddha. |
| there was no house but someone had died in it | There was no house in which nobody had died. |
| kinsmen | Relatives. |
| Mark! | Notice! / Pay attention! |
Semicolons
- Use: A semicolon can join closely related independent clauses when no conjunction is needed.
- Three simple sentences: Those who are born cannot avoid death. Death comes after old age. This is the nature of living beings.
- Rhythm: Semicolons connect ideas in one flowing statement; separate sentences give each idea a stronger pause.
Different Ways of Understanding Grief
Grief — A natural emotional response to loss or significant change; it is personal and can be expressed in different ways.
| Common responses to grief | How to support a grieving person |
|---|---|
| Sadness; anger; guilt or self-reproach; anxiety; loneliness; fatigue; disbelief, especially after a sudden death. | Be patient and show that you care. Some people want to talk or reminisce; others may not want to share their grief. |
| Grief differs from person to person and may involve changes in feelings and behaviour. | Offer support without forcing conversation, and let the person know you are there for them. |
Amitai Etzioni’s Account: Good Grief
- No fixed stages: There is no single correct way to grieve, and people need not experience emotions in a prescribed order.
- Central idea: Rather than asking why a loss happened, survivors can focus on what they can do for one another.
- Practical support: Etzioni’s family and friends stay connected, care for the young child and support the bereaved widow.
- Consolation: Caring actions and companionship offer the family the comfort it can find.
| Perspective | Main idea | Response to grief |
|---|---|---|
| The Buddha’s sermon | Death is unavoidable and affects every family. | Recognising that loss is shared can help a person look beyond their own grief. |
| A Guide to Coping with the Death of a Loved One | Grief is natural, personal and expressed in many ways. | Offer patient, respectful support. |
| Good Grief | There is no single right way or fixed sequence for mourning. | Focus on caring for one another through practical help and companionship. |
Reflections on Joy, Sorrow and Remembrance
- Kahlil Gibran: Joy and sorrow are inseparable; sorrow can deepen a person’s capacity for joy.
- Tagore: Remember the departed with thankfulness for their life. Death is pictured not as a light simply extinguished, but as a lamp put out because dawn has come.
How can we help someone experiencing grief?
Quick recap
- Kisa Gotami learns that no household is untouched by death.
- The Buddha helps her recognise the universality and inevitability of loss.
- Grief is natural, personal and may involve many different feelings.
- Support grieving people patiently; respect whether or not they want to talk.
- There is no single correct sequence for mourning; practical care can bring comfort.
- Gibran links joy and sorrow, while Tagore presents death as a lamp put out at the coming of dawn.
English — ALL CHAPTERS
1
A Letter To God
2
Nelson Mandela Long Walk To Freedom
3
Two Stories About Flying
4
From The Diary Of Anne Frank
5
Glimpses Of India
6
Mijbil The Otter: Gavin Maxwell
7
Madam Rides The Bus
8
The Sermons At Benares
9
The Proposal
1
A Triumph of Surgery
2
The Thief’s Story
3
The Midnight Visitor
4
A Question of Trust
5
Footprints without Feet
6
The Making of a Scientist
7
The Necklace
8
Bholi
9
The Book That Saved the Earth