Class 12 Commerce . Business Studies . Business Studies Part I . Controlling

Chapter 8: CONTROLLING

Ch 8

Business Studies

Class 12 Commerce

Lecture 1

Understanding the Meaning of Controlling

Reference video · Lecture 1Understanding the Meaning of Controlling

Controlling in Practice

Departure Control System (DCS)

  • Purpose: A DCS automates key airline airport operations, including passenger check-in, boarding passes, baggage acceptance and boarding load control.
  • Information: It can retrieve updated passenger reservations from an airline’s computer reservation system through the passenger name record (PNR).
  • Tracking: Passenger reservations can be updated to statuses such as checked in, boarded or flown.
  • Control link: By tracking operations, the system helps managers spot issues and take corrective action before they harm the business.

Meaning and Nature of Controlling

Definition

Controlling — The management function of ensuring that organisational activities follow plans and that resources are used effectively and efficiently to achieve predetermined goals.

Key Features

  • Goal-oriented: Controlling seeks planned results and keeps work directed towards organisational goals.
  • Pervasive: It is needed by managers at top, middle and lower levels, within their areas of responsibility.
  • Universal: Controlling is required in businesses as well as institutions such as schools, hospitals, the military and clubs.
  • Corrective: It identifies departures of actual performance from standards, examines their causes and supports corrective action.
  • Continuous cycle: Controlling does not simply end management’s work; its findings help improve plans for the next period.

How Controlling Feeds Future Planning

  1. Compare actual performance with standards
  2. Identify and analyse deviations
  3. Take corrective action
  4. Use lessons from problems to improve future plans
Controlling and Planning
PointPlanningControlling
Role in the management cycleSets objectives and standards in advance.Checks performance against plans and identifies deviations.
ConnectionProvides the standards that controlling uses.Uses its findings to support better planning in the next cycle.
Key terms
Standard
A planned level or measure of performance used as a basis for comparison.
Deviation
The difference between actual performance and the set standard.
Corrective action
Action taken to address the causes of a deviation and bring performance towards the plan.
Pervasive function
A function required at every level of management and across different types of organisations.

Why is controlling not simply the last function of management?

Answer: Controlling identifies and analyses deviations, prompts corrective action and provides lessons for better planning in the next management cycle.

Quick recap

  • Controlling ensures that organisational activities follow plans and resources support predetermined goals.
  • It is goal-oriented, pervasive and required at all levels of management and in different kinds of organisations.
  • Controlling compares actual performance with standards and identifies deviations.
  • Managers analyse deviations and take corrective action.
  • Findings from controlling improve planning in the next management cycle.
Lecture 2

Importance of Controlling

Reference video · Lecture 2Importance of Controlling
Definition

Managerial control — According to Koontz and O’Donnell, managerial control measures accomplishment against standards and corrects deviations to ensure objectives are achieved according to plans.

Benefits of Controlling

How Controlling Helps an Organisation
BenefitHow it helps
Accomplishing organisational goalsMeasures progress, identifies deviations and indicates corrective action to keep the organisation on track.
Judging accuracy of standardsChecks whether standards are accurate and objective; changing organisational or environmental conditions may require their revision.
Efficient use of resourcesEnsures activities follow predetermined standards, reducing wastage and spoilage.
Employee motivationClarifies expected work and appraisal standards in advance, encouraging better performance.
Order and disciplineClose checks on employee activities discourage dishonest behaviour and help maintain discipline.
Coordination in actionCoordinated standards guide departments and employees towards overall organisational objectives.

Controlling and Goal Achievement

  1. Measure progress against organisational goals.
  2. Identify deviations from standards.
  3. Take corrective action.
  4. Keep activities on track and help achieve objectives.

Limitations of Controlling

Main Limitations
LimitationExplanation
Difficulty setting quantitative standardsMorale, job satisfaction and human behaviour are difficult to quantify, making performance measurement and comparison harder.
Little control over external factorsAn enterprise generally cannot control government policies, technological changes or competition.
Employee resistanceEmployees may view control as a restriction on freedom and object to close monitoring, such as CCTV surveillance.
Costly affairControl takes time, effort and money; small enterprises may not be able to afford expensive systems.
★ Remember
  • Check that the cost of installing and operating a control system does not exceed its benefits.

Example: Control Through Computer Monitoring

  • Monitoring: A New York import-export company suspected employee theft. Corporate Defense Strategies (CDS) advised the firm to install software that secretly logged the suspects’ keystrokes and sent encrypted reports.
  • Misconduct found: Two employees deleted processed orders from company records, pocketed the revenue and built their own business.
  • Outcome: The software revealed their plan to steal electronics; police arrested them when they entered the warehouse.
  • Scale: The employees were charged with embezzling 3 million dollars over two and a half years from a firm earning 25 million dollars annually.
Key terms
Controlling
Measuring performance against standards, identifying deviations and taking corrective action.
Standard
A predetermined basis for measuring and evaluating performance.
Deviation
A difference between actual performance and the set standard.

State four ways controlling benefits an organisation.

Answer: It helps achieve organisational goals, checks the accuracy of standards, improves resource use and motivates employees. It also promotes discipline and coordination.

Explain any two limitations of controlling.

Answer: Standards related to morale and job satisfaction can be difficult to quantify. Also, businesses generally cannot control external factors such as government policies, technology and competition.

Quick recap

  • Controlling measures accomplishment against standards and corrects deviations to help achieve planned objectives.
  • It supports goal achievement, accurate standards, efficient resource use, employee motivation, discipline and coordination.
  • Qualitative areas such as morale, satisfaction and behaviour can be difficult to measure.
  • Businesses generally have little control over external factors such as government policy, technology and competition.
  • Employee resistance and high costs can limit control systems.
  • Control-system costs should not exceed the benefits they provide.
Lecture 3

Relationship between Planning and Controlling

Reference video · Lecture 3Relationship between Planning and Controlling

How Planning and Controlling Are Related

Definition

Planning and controlling — They are inseparable management functions: planning sets the standards, while controlling checks performance against them and helps keep events aligned with plans.

Planning vs Controlling
PointPlanningControlling
Main rolePrescribes the course of action and desired performance.Evaluates whether decisions have been translated into desired action.
BasisSets performance standards.Uses the standards set by planning to measure actual performance.
Time focusForward-looking: plans are based on forecasts about future conditions.Backward-looking when it reviews past performance and identifies deviations.
How they connectWithout control, plans cannot be checked or corrected.Without plans and standards, there is no basis for control.

Two-way relationship

  • Planning enables control: Plans provide the standards needed to measure performance and identify deviations.
  • Control improves planning: Information from past performance and corrective action helps managers plan better for the future.
  • Both time directions: Planning looks ahead but uses past experience; controlling looks back but aims to improve future performance.
Memory hook Prepzy tip

Plan sets; control checks

Planning sets the target; controlling checks progress and feeds lessons back into future plans.

The Controlling Process

Definition

Controlling process — A systematic sequence for setting standards, measuring performance, comparing results, analysing deviations and taking corrective action.

Five steps

  1. Set performance standards.
  2. Measure actual performance.
  3. Compare actual performance with standards.
  4. Analyse deviations and their causes.
  5. Take corrective action.

1. Setting Performance Standards

Definition

Performance standards — Benchmarks or criteria against which actual performance is measured and towards which an organisation works.

Types and qualities of standards

  • Quantitative standards: Expressed numerically, such as cost, revenue, units produced or sold, and time taken.
  • Qualitative standards: Describe less directly measurable aims, such as improving goodwill or employee motivation.
  • Make them measurable: Use precise quantities wherever possible; define qualitative aims through observable measures.
  • Keep them flexible: Standards may need revision when internal or external business conditions change.
  • Example: Reduce defects from 10 to 5 per 1,000 units by the end of the quarter.
Standards Used in Functional Areas
ProductionMarketingHuman Resource ManagementFinance and Accounting
QuantitySales volumeLabour relationsCapital expenditures
QualitySales expenseLabour turnoverInventories
CostAdvertising expendituresLabour absenteeismFlow of capital
Individual job performanceIndividual salesperson’s performance—Liquidity

2. Measuring Actual Performance

Measurement methods and examples

  • Reliable measurement: Make it objective and, as far as possible, use the same units as the standards.
  • Methods: Personal observation, sample checking and performance reports.
  • Timing: Measure during work where possible, not only after completion; for example, check parts before assembly or monitor air safety continuously.
  • Employee performance: A superior may prepare a performance report.
  • Company performance: Ratios such as gross profit ratio, net profit ratio and return on investment may be calculated periodically.
  • Marketing and production: Track units sold or market share; production efficiency can be assessed through units produced and defective units.
  • Sample checking: Large organisations may inspect randomly selected products when checking every item is impractical; small organisations may check each item.

3. Comparing Performance with Standards

  • Comparison: Place actual results against the standards to reveal deviations between actual and desired performance.
  • Easier comparison: Quantitative standards make differences straightforward to identify; for example, compare a worker’s weekly output with the weekly target.

4. Analysing Deviations

Definition

Deviation — The difference between actual performance and the standard or desired result.

How managers analyse deviations

  • Set an acceptable range: Some deviation is expected, so determine the limits within which results are acceptable.
  • Prioritise key areas: Deviations in important business areas need more urgent attention than those in less significant areas.
  • Find the cause: Possible causes include unrealistic standards, defective processes, inadequate resources, structural drawbacks, organisational constraints and external factors beyond the organisation’s control.
  • Act on the cause: Identify the exact cause before choosing corrective action; report deviations and causes to the appropriate level.
Critical Point Control vs Management by Exception
PointCritical Point ControlManagement by Exception
MeaningFocus control on key result areas (KRAs) critical to organisational success.Bring only significant deviations beyond permissible limits to management’s attention.
ReasonChecking every activity is neither easy nor economical; failure at a critical point can harm the whole organisation.Trying to control everything can result in controlling nothing.
ExampleA 5% rise in labour cost may matter more than a 15% rise in postal charges.If a 2% rise in labour cost is acceptable, report rises beyond 2%; a 5% deviation needs immediate priority.

Advantages of these approaches

  • Saves time and effort: Managers deal with significant deviations rather than every small issue.
  • Focuses attention: Managerial talent is directed towards important areas and critical problems receive timely action.
  • Supports delegation: Routine issues can be handled by subordinates, supporting delegation of authority and improving employee morale.

5. Taking Corrective Action

When and how to correct performance

  • Within limits: No corrective action is needed when deviations remain within the acceptable range.
  • Beyond limits: Important deviations need prompt attention to prevent recurrence and help achieve standards.
  • Examples: Train employees if production targets are missed; add workers or equipment and allow overtime if a project is behind schedule.
  • Revise standards if needed: When a deviation cannot be corrected through managerial action, the standards themselves may need revision.
A manager presents a remedial plan of action to address deviations in sales performance.
A manager presents a remedial plan of action to address deviations in sales performance.
Key terms
Performance standard
A benchmark used to assess actual performance.
Deviation
The difference between actual performance and the standard.
Critical Point Control
Concentrating control on key result areas crucial to success.
Management by Exception
Bringing significant deviations beyond permissible limits to management’s attention.

Explain why planning and controlling are interdependent.

Answer: Planning sets the standards that controlling needs to measure performance. Controlling identifies deviations and provides information from experience that improves future planning.

What is management by exception?

Answer: It is the principle of bringing only significant deviations beyond the permissible limit to management’s notice, so managerial attention is focused on issues requiring action.

Quick recap

  • Planning establishes standards; controlling checks performance against them.
  • Planning and controlling are interdependent and both draw on past experience while influencing future performance.
  • The control process has five steps: set standards, measure, compare, analyse deviations and correct.
  • Standards may be quantitative or qualitative; make them measurable and flexible.
  • Use critical point control for key result areas and management by exception for significant deviations.
  • Correct deviations beyond acceptable limits, or revise standards when required.
Lecture 4

Key Terms and Summary

Reference video · Lecture 4Key Terms and Summary
Definition

Controlling — The process of ensuring that actual activities conform to planned activities.

Importance of Controlling

  • Goals: Helps the organisation accomplish its objectives.
  • Standards: Helps judge whether performance standards are accurate.
  • Resources: Supports their efficient utilisation.
  • Morale and discipline: Boosts employee morale and promotes order and discipline.
  • Coordination: Aligns different activities so they work towards common targets.

Limitations of Controlling

  • External factors: An organisation cannot control factors outside its control system.
  • Employee resistance: Employees may resist the control system.
  • Cost: Controlling can be expensive, particularly for small organisations.
  • Quantitative standards: Some performance areas cannot easily be measured quantitatively, reducing the effectiveness of control.

Control Process

  1. Set performance standards
  2. Measure actual performance
  3. Compare actual performance with standards
  4. Analyse deviations
  5. Take corrective action

Planning and Controlling

Planning vs Controlling
PointPlanningControlling
Role in managementInitiates the management processCompletes the management process
RelationshipPlans provide the basis for controlChecks whether activities follow plans
ConnectionPlanning and controlling are inseparable; without control, plans may go astrayControl depends on plans and helps keep their execution on track

Techniques of Managerial Control

TypeTechniques
TraditionalPersonal observation; statistical reports; breakeven analysis; budgetary control
ModernReturn on investment (ROI); ratio analysis; responsibility accounting; management audit; PERT and CPM; Management Information System (MIS)

Other Key Terms

  • Control approaches: Critical point control; management by exception.
  • Named techniques: Breakeven analysis; budgetary control; return on investment; ratio analysis; responsibility accounting; management audit; PERT and CPM; Management Information System.

State the steps in the control process.

Answer: Set standards, measure actual performance, compare it with standards, analyse deviations and take corrective action.

Give two limitations of controlling.

Answer: It cannot control external factors, and employees may resist the control system. It may also be costly or difficult to use when quantitative standards cannot be set.

Quick recap

  • Controlling ensures actual activities conform to planned activities.
  • It supports goal achievement, accurate standards, efficient resource use, morale, discipline and coordination.
  • External factors, employee resistance, high costs and difficulty setting quantitative standards limit control.
  • The control process moves from setting standards to corrective action.
  • Planning starts management; controlling completes it, and both depend on each other.
  • Traditional techniques include personal observation, statistical reports, breakeven analysis and budgetary control.
  • Modern techniques include ROI, ratio analysis, responsibility accounting, management audit, PERT and CPM, and MIS.

Business Studies — ALL CHAPTERS

1

NATURE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF MANAGEMENT

View

2

PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT

View

3

BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT

View

4

Planning

View

5

ORGANISING

View

6

Staffing

View

7

DIRECTING

View

8

CONTROLLING

View

9

Financial Management

View

10

Marketing

View

11

Consumer Protection

View