Class 11 Humanities . Political Science . Political Theory . Nationalism
Chapter 7: NATIONALISM
Ch 7
Political Science
Class 11 Humanities
Introducing Nationalism
Understanding Nationalism
Meaning and continuing relevance
- Nationalism: A powerful political creed that has shaped world affairs; there is no precise, widely accepted definition.
- Common associations: Patriotism, national flags and willingness to sacrifice for one’s country.
- Public symbol: India’s Republic Day parade brings out ideas of national power, strength and diversity.
- Globalisation: Nationalism remains relevant; examples include support for the Indian cricket team and Indians abroad watching Bollywood films.
- Nation
- What makes a nation and what it aspires to are questions the chapter explores; no definition is settled here.
- Nation-state
- A political form associated with membership in a nation and a shared political identity.
- National self-determination
- The claim that a nation should be able to determine its political status, including whether it seeks statehood.
- Separatist movement
- A movement expressing nationalist demands that may include separation or separate statehood.
- Pan-Arab union
- The aspiration to unite Arab countries.
Nationalism’s Effects and Historical Development
A force that can unite and divide
- Loyalty: Nationalism can inspire intense attachment to a nation.
- Unity and division: It can unite people, but also generate deep hatred, conflict, bitterness and war.
- Political change: It has helped people resist oppressive rule and contributed to the breakup of empires and states.
- Changing boundaries: Nationalist struggles have drawn and redrawn state boundaries; separatist struggles continue within existing states.
Nationalism through time
- During the last two centuries or moreNationalism emerged as a compelling political creed that helped shape history.
- Nineteenth-century EuropeNationalism helped unite smaller kingdoms into larger nation-states, including Germany and Italy; many new states also formed in Latin America.
- Early twentieth centuryNationalism contributed to the breakup of the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires.
- The last century or moreA process of consolidation also took place in India.
- Since 1960Even apparently stable nation-states have faced nationalist demands, including demands for separate statehood.
How nation-state consolidation develops
- Smaller kingdoms unite and state boundaries consolidate.
- Local dialects and loyalties gradually consolidate into common languages and state loyalties.
- People acquire a political identity based on membership in the nation-state.
| Process | How nationalism acts | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidation | Unites smaller political units and strengthens state loyalties. | Germany and Italy; new states in Latin America. |
| Breakup of empires and colonial rule | Challenges large empires or foreign control and supports independent nation-states. | Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires; British, French, Dutch and Portuguese empires in Asia and Africa; anti-colonial struggles in India and other colonies. |
| Separatist demands | Challenges the unity of an existing state and may seek separate statehood. | Quebecois in Canada; Basques in northern Spain; Kurds in Turkey and Iraq; Tamils in Sri Lanka. |
Different nationalist aims
- Anti-colonial nationalism: India and other colonies struggled for freedom from foreign rule and to establish independent nation-states.
- Separatist nationalism: Groups or regions may demand separation from an existing state; such struggles threaten to divide states.
- Pan-Arab nationalism: May seek to unite Arab countries in a wider union.
- Indian context: Some groups in India also use the language of nationalism.
Questions of Nationhood and Statehood
Issues explored in the chapter
- Nationhood: What makes people form nations, and what do nations aspire to?
- Loyalty: Why are people willing to sacrifice, or even die, for their nation?
- Statehood: How are claims to nationhood linked to claims for statehood?
- Self-determination: Do nations have a right to statehood, or can nationalist claims be met without granting separate statehood?
How can nationalism both unite and divide people?
Give examples of nationalism contributing to the formation or breakup of states and empires.
How do pan-Arab nationalism and separatist nationalism differ in their aims?
Quick recap
- Nationalism is a powerful political creed, but it has no precise, widely accepted definition.
- It can inspire loyalty and unity, but also conflict, war and the breakup of states.
- In nineteenth-century Europe, nationalism helped consolidate smaller kingdoms into nation-states such as Germany and Italy.
- Nationalism contributed to the breakup of empires and inspired anti-colonial struggles for independence.
- Since 1960, nationalist demands—including demands for separate statehood—have continued within existing states.
- Nationalism raises questions about nationhood, statehood and self-determination; it remains relevant in a globalised world.
Nations and Nationalism
What Is a Nation?
- Nation: A collective community whose members imagine themselves as belonging together and aspire to an independent political existence.
- Distinct from kinship: Nationals need not know one another personally or share ties of descent.
Shared Beliefs
- Collective belief: A nation exists because its members believe they belong together and share a collective identity.
- Common vision: Like members of a team, people see themselves as a group and aspire to shape a shared political future.
History
- Continuity: Nations see themselves as linked to the past and extending into the future.
- Collective memory: Memories, legends and historical records help people express a continuing national identity.
Territory
- Homeland: A shared past and long residence in a territory help people imagine themselves as one community.
- Significance: Nations may describe their homeland as a motherland, fatherland or holy land; competing claims to territory can cause conflict.
Shared Political Ideals
- Shared vision: Members of a nation aspire to build a state based on common values such as democracy, secularism and liberalism.
- Citizens’ obligations: Recognising one another’s rights and accepting shared obligations strengthens the nation.
Political Identity and Cultural Identity
- Cultural bonds: A common language, religion, festivals or symbols can bring people together, but these identities are diverse.
- Democratic basis: A nation is best united by constitutional political values, not by requiring everyone to share one religion, race or language.
National Self-Determination
Self-Determination: Key Periods
- Nineteenth centuryIn Europe, the idea of one culture–one state gained acceptance.
- After World War IThe Treaty of Versailles established several small, newly independent states, but could not meet every self-determination claim.
- Twentieth centuryNational liberation movements in Asia and Africa asserted self-determination against colonial rule.
Consequences of Reordering European Boundaries
- The one culture–one state idea influenced the redrawing of boundaries after World War I.
- The Treaty of Versailles created new states and gave political recognition to groups that saw themselves as distinct nations and wanted to govern themselves.
- It proved impossible to satisfy every self-determination claim; millions were displaced or expelled from homes they had lived in for generations, and many suffered communal violence.
- New states still contained multiple ethnic and cultural communities; minorities were often disadvantaged, leaving equal citizenship unresolved.
- The reorganisation therefore brought recognition to some groups but also caused severe human suffering and failed to create states containing only one ethnic community.
Self-Determination in Asia and Africa
A Democratic Response to Self-Determination Claims
- New claims challenge states to accommodate national, cultural and ethnic identities.
- Creating new states does not necessarily resolve the underlying problems of diversity.
- Make existing states more democratic and equal.
- Enable people with different identities to live together as partners and equal citizens.
- Respecting minority rights and cultural identities can strengthen unity and loyalty to the state.
Basque Demand for Self-Determination
- Imagined community
- A community held together by members’ shared belief in a collective identity.
- National identity
- A sense of belonging to a nation, expressed through shared beliefs, history, territory and political aspirations.
- National self-determination
- A nation’s claim to govern itself and shape its future.
- Nation-state
- A state associated with a nation; it may contain more than one cultural or ethnic community.
What makes a nation different from a family or kinship group?
Why should democratic nations be based on political rather than compulsory cultural identity?
What is national self-determination, and what democratic approach can address its challenges?
Quick recap
- A nation is an imagined community sustained by collective belief, not necessarily by shared ancestry, religion or language.
- Nations express identity through shared history, territory, political ideals and aspirations for the future.
- Democratic national identity is strongest when based on shared political values, equal rights and mutual obligations.
- National self-determination seeks self-government; boundary changes brought political recognition to some groups but also caused displacement, violence and minority disadvantage.
- Respecting minorities and making existing states more equal can support unity and loyalty.
- The Basque case illustrates the debate between regional autonomy, separate statehood and competing views of national identity.
Nationalism and Pluralism
Recognising Cultural Pluralism
Inclusive National Identity
- Recognition: Groups need to be acknowledged as part of the national community.
- Inclusion: National identity should recognise the importance and distinct contributions of all cultural communities.
- Democratic challenge: Recognition and protection may not satisfy every group; some may still demand a separate state.
- Globalisation: Global connections have grown, yet nationalist aspirations continue to motivate communities.
Self-Determination and Statehood
Why Separate Statehood for Every Group Is Problematic
- Many groups seek recognition as distinct nations
- Granting each group an independent state is impractical
- It could create numerous states too small to be economically or politically viable
- It could also multiply the problems of minorities
Identity, Citizenship and Democracy
- Multiple identities: People may identify with gender, caste, religion, language and region, and value these identities together.
- Citizenship: A democratic political identity should encompass people’s different identities and allow them to express them freely.
- Warning: Intolerant, homogenising nationalism can turn identity claims into division and violence.
Tagore’s Critique of Nationalism
| Opposing Western imperialism | Rejecting Western civilisation | |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Resisting colonial domination and asserting India’s independence | Rejecting Western ideas and influences as a whole |
| Tagore’s view | Necessary; he opposed colonial rule | Not necessary; India could learn from abroad while remaining rooted in its own culture |
- Cultural minority
- A community whose cultural identity differs from that of the majority in a country.
- Group rights
- Rights that protect a community’s identity or provide it with representation.
- National self-determination
- The right of a nationality to determine its political status, including democratic rights within a state.
- Inclusive national identity
- A shared national identity that recognises the importance and contributions of different communities.
Why can it be undesirable to grant independent statehood to every group seeking self-determination?
What was Tagore’s distinction between opposing imperialism and rejecting Western civilisation?
Quick recap
- Plural societies can protect minority cultures and recognise communities through group rights.
- An inclusive national identity recognises the contributions of all cultural communities.
- Self-determination need not mean independent statehood; it can mean democratic rights within a state.
- Granting every group separate statehood could create unviable states and multiply minority problems.
- People have multiple identities, and democratic citizenship should encompass them.
- Tagore opposed imperialism but supported learning across cultures and placing humanity above narrow patriotism.
Political Science — ALL CHAPTERS
1
Constitution: Why And How?
2
Rights In The Indian Constitution
3
Election And Representation
4
Executive
5
Legislature
6
Judiciary
7
Federalism
8
Local Governments
9
Constitution as A Living Document
10
The Philosophy Of The Constitution
1
INTRODUCTION TO POLITICAL THEORY
2
FREEDOM OVERVIEW
3
EQUALITY
4
SOCIAL JUSTICE
5
RIGHTS
6
CITIZENSHIP
7
NATIONALISM
8
SECULARISM