Class 10 . Social Science . Democratic Politics II . Power Sharing

Chapter 1: POWER SHARING

Ch 1

Social Science

Class 10

Lecture 1

Introduction

Reference video · Lecture 1Introduction

Power Sharing in a Democracy

  • Core idea: Democracy works best when political power is shared rather than concentrated in one place or group.
  • Chapter focus: The examples of Belgium and Sri Lanka show how different approaches to power-sharing affect social harmony and national unity.

The Chapter’s Focus

  • Power-sharing: Power is distributed among government institutions and across different levels and groups in society.
  • Democratic principle: People affected by decisions should have a voice in how they are governed.
  • Purpose: Sharing power helps reduce social conflict and supports political stability and national unity.
  • Forms: Power may be shared among government organs, levels of government, social groups, and political parties or pressure groups.

Quick recap

  • Democracy requires that power not be concentrated in one government organ.
  • The legislature, executive and judiciary share government power.
  • Belgium and Sri Lanka illustrate how democracies respond to demands for power-sharing.
  • The stories lead to general conclusions about why power-sharing is needed.
  • Different forms of power-sharing are discussed in the following two chapters.
Lecture 2

Belgium and Sri Lanka

Reference video · Lecture 2Belgium and Sri Lanka

Power Sharing in Democracy

  • Comparative examples: Belgium and Sri Lanka illustrate two different ways democracies respond to demands for power-sharing.
  • Main lesson: Accommodating diverse communities can protect national unity, while refusing to share power can deepen conflict.

Ethnic Composition and Community Tensions

Language communities and regions of Belgium.
Language communities and regions of Belgium.
Potential Majority–Minority Tensions
CountryMajority situationRisk if power is imposed
BelgiumDutch speakers were the national majority but a minority in Brussels.A national majority could impose its will on French- and German-speaking communities; competing claims over Brussels could lead to partition.
Sri LankaThe Sinhala-speaking community had a larger majority.The Sinhala majority could impose its will on the Tamil-speaking population.

Majoritarianism in Sri Lanka

Geographic distribution of Sinhala, Sri Lankan Tamil, Indian Tamil and Muslim communities in Sri Lanka.
Geographic distribution of Sinhala, Sri Lankan Tamil, Indian Tamil and Muslim communities in Sri Lanka.

From Majoritarian Policies to Civil War

  1. Sinhala-majority policies restricted Tamil language recognition and favoured Sinhala people in education and government employment.
  2. Tamils experienced discrimination and growing alienation.
  3. Tamil parties and groups demanded official recognition of Tamil, regional autonomy, and equal opportunities in education and jobs.
  4. Demands for greater autonomy in Tamil-populated provinces were repeatedly denied; by the 1980s, organisations demanded an independent Tamil Eelam in the north and east.
  5. Distrust escalated into civil war, killing thousands from both communities, forcing families to flee as refugees and causing many to lose their livelihoods.
Definition

Civil war — A violent conflict between opposing groups within one country that becomes intense enough to resemble a war.

Impact and End of the Civil War

  • Impact: The war caused a severe setback to Sri Lanka’s social, cultural and economic life, despite its strong record in economic development, education and health.
  • End: The civil war ended in 2009.

Key Developments

  1. 1948Sri Lanka became independent.
  2. 1950s–1960sTensions between Dutch- and French-speaking communities in Belgium grew, especially in Brussels.
  3. 1956An Act made Sinhala the sole official language of Sri Lanka.
  4. 1980sTamil organisations demanded an independent Tamil Eelam in northern and eastern Sri Lanka.
  5. 2009The Sri Lankan civil war ended.
Key terms
Ethnic
A social division based on shared culture and a belief in common descent.
Majoritarianism
Rule by the majority while disregarding minority needs and wishes.
Regional autonomy
The ability of a region to govern some of its own affairs.
Civil war
Intense violent conflict between groups within the same country.

What measures established Sinhala supremacy in Sri Lanka?

Answer: The 1956 Act made Sinhala the sole official language; policies favoured Sinhala applicants for university places and government jobs; and the constitution directed the state to protect and foster Buddhism.

What did Sri Lankan Tamils demand, and what was the outcome?

Answer: They sought official recognition of Tamil, regional autonomy, and equal opportunities in education and jobs. Repeated denial of autonomy demands fuelled conflict; by the 1980s, some organisations demanded an independent Tamil Eelam, and civil war followed.

Quick recap

  • In a democracy, power is shared among the legislature, executive and judiciary rather than held by one organ alone.
  • Belgium has Dutch-, French- and German-speaking communities; Brussels has a French-speaking majority.
  • Belgium’s Dutch-speaking community was a national majority but a minority in Brussels, creating a risk of conflict over the capital.
  • In Sri Lanka, about 74% speak Sinhala and 18% speak Tamil; Sri Lankan Tamils are 13% and Indian Tamils 5% of the population.
  • Sri Lanka’s Sinhala-speaking majority adopted policies that privileged Sinhala language and Buddhism.
  • Discrimination and denied autonomy demands increased Tamil alienation and distrust; the civil war caused deaths, displacement and major national damage and ended in 2009.
Lecture 3

Accommodation in Belgium

Reference video · Lecture 3Accommodation in Belgium

Belgium’s Power-Sharing Arrangements

Constitutional Changes

  1. 1970–1993Belgium amended its Constitution four times to create arrangements that respected regional and cultural differences.
Main Features of the Belgian Model
ArrangementHow it worksPurpose
Central governmentDutch-speaking and French-speaking ministers have equal numbers.Neither major linguistic community can dominate the central government.
Special lawsThey need the support of a majority of members in each linguistic group.One community cannot make decisions unilaterally.
State governmentsMany central powers are transferred to the governments of the two regions; these governments are not subordinate to the centre.Regional interests receive decision-making power.
Brussels governmentBrussels has a separate government with equal representation for both communities.The French-speaking community accepted equality in Brussels because Dutch speakers accepted equality at the centre.
Community governmentElected by people of each language community—Dutch, French or German—wherever they live.It handles cultural, educational and language-related matters.

Language and National Unity

  • Languages: Belgium has Dutch-, French- and German-speaking communities; Brussels uses both French and Dutch, including on public signs.
  • Outcome: The arrangements have helped prevent civic conflict between the major communities and reduced the risk of the country splitting along linguistic lines.
  • European Union: Brussels was chosen as the headquarters when European countries came together to form the European Union.
Belgium vs Sri Lanka
PointBelgiumSri Lanka
ApproachLeaders respected different communities and regions and established mutually acceptable power-sharing arrangements.The majority community sought dominance and refused to share power adequately.
EffectPower sharing supported national unity.Majoritarianism could undermine national unity.
Cartoon showing challenges faced by Germany’s grand coalition government.
Cartoon showing challenges faced by Germany’s grand coalition government.

Why Power Sharing Is Desirable

Two Reasons for Power Sharing
ReasonBasisWhy it matters
PrudentialCareful consideration of gains and losses; power sharing can produce better outcomes.It reduces conflict between social groups, helping prevent violence and political instability and protecting national unity.
MoralPower sharing is valuable in itself and is part of the spirit of democracy.People affected by decisions have a right to be consulted and participate; participation gives citizens a stake in the system and strengthens government legitimacy.

Majority Rule Without Power Sharing

  1. A majority imposes its will on minorities
  2. Minority groups face oppression and social conflict increases
  3. Conflict may lead to violence and political instability
  4. The country’s unity—and ultimately the majority’s interests—can also be harmed
Key terms
Prudential reason
A reason based on carefully weighing likely gains and losses.
Moral reason
A reason based on the value of power sharing and democratic participation in themselves.
Community government
A government elected by members of one language community to manage cultural, educational and language matters.

Whose parents are more likely to succeed in obtaining their child’s preferred medium of instruction: Annette’s or Selvi’s?

Answer: Annette’s parents are more likely to succeed. Belgium’s power-sharing arrangements protect linguistic communities and provide ways to address language-related concerns. Sri Lanka’s majoritarian approach gave less weight to Tamil demands.

Quick recap

  • Belgium amended its Constitution four times between 1970 and 1993 to accommodate regional and cultural differences.
  • Equal representation and special-law protections prevent either major linguistic group from deciding alone.
  • Regional state governments and language-based community governments hold important powers.
  • Belgium’s arrangements helped reduce conflict and protect national unity; Brussels became the European Union’s headquarters.
  • Prudential reasons support power sharing for its beneficial outcomes, such as stability.
  • Moral reasons value power sharing as a democratic right and as meaningful participation.
Lecture 4

Forms of Power-sharing

Reference video · Lecture 4Forms of Power-sharing

Why Power Is Shared

  • Earlier view: Political power was thought to belong in one person or group, because distributing it was believed to slow decisions and enforcement.
  • Democratic principle: People are the source of political power and govern themselves through institutions.
  • Inclusive government: Diverse groups and views should have a voice in shaping public policies; power should be shared as widely as possible.
Editorial cartoon showing leaders tightening their control over democracy.
Editorial cartoon showing leaders tightening their control over democracy.

Power Shared Among Government Organs

Definition

Horizontal distribution of power — Power is divided among government organs at the same level, such as the legislature, executive and judiciary.

  • Purpose: Separate powers prevent any one organ from exercising unlimited power.
  • Checks and balances: Each organ can limit or check the others, maintaining a balance of power.
  • Examples: Ministers and officials are accountable to Parliament or State Assemblies; judges can review executive actions and laws made by legislatures.

Power Shared Among Levels of Government

Definition

Vertical distribution of power — Power is divided among higher and lower levels of government, such as national, state and local governments.

  • National level: The general government for the whole country is called the federal government; in India it is the Central or Union Government.
  • Regional level: In India, provincial or regional governments are called State Governments.
  • Constitutional division: In countries with multiple levels of government, the constitution lays down their powers. Belgium adopted this arrangement; Sri Lanka did not.
  • Local level: The division can extend below the state level to municipalities and panchayats.

Power Shared Among Social Groups

Definition

Power-sharing among social groups — Power is distributed among groups such as religious and linguistic communities, as well as socially weaker sections and women.

  • Belgium: Community government is an example of power-sharing among social groups.
  • Representation: Constitutional or legal arrangements, including reserved constituencies in India, help weaker sections and women gain representation in legislatures and administration.
  • Purpose: Giving diverse groups a fair share of power reduces alienation and helps minority communities participate in government.

Power Shared Through Parties and Groups

  • Political competition: Citizens choose among parties competing for power, preventing power from remaining in one hand.
  • Long-term sharing: Different parties represent different ideologies and social groups, so power can shift among them over time.
  • Coalition government: Two or more parties may form an alliance to contest elections; if elected, they share power in a coalition government.
  • Pressure groups and movements: Groups such as traders, industrialists, farmers and industrial workers influence government through committees or by affecting decision-making.
Key terms
Checks and balances
A system in which government organs check one another to prevent unlimited power.
Horizontal distribution
Power-sharing among government organs at the same level.
Vertical distribution
Power-sharing among higher and lower levels of government.
Coalition government
A government formed by two or more parties that share power.

What is horizontal power-sharing, and why is it important?

Answer: It divides power among the legislature, executive and judiciary at the same level. Checks and balances prevent any organ from exercising unlimited power.

Name the four main forms of power-sharing.

Answer: Among government organs; among levels of government; among social groups; and among political parties, pressure groups and movements.

Quick recap

  • Democracy requires people and diverse groups to have a voice in public decisions.
  • Horizontal sharing divides power among the legislature, executive and judiciary.
  • Checks and balances prevent any government organ from becoming unlimited in power.
  • Vertical sharing divides authority among national, state and local governments.
  • Social-group representation, including reserved constituencies, gives minorities and weaker sections a share in power.
  • Political competition, coalitions and organised groups influence or share governmental power.

Social Science — ALL CHAPTERS

1

RESOURCES AND DEVELOPMENT

View

2

FOREST AND WILDLIFE RESOURCES

View

3

WATER RESOURCES

View

4

AGRICULTURE

View

5

MINERALS AND ENERGY RESOURCES

View

6

MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES

View

7

LIFELINES OF NATIONAL ECONOMY

View

1

POWER SHARING

View

2

FEDERALISM

View

3

GENDER, RELIGION AND CASTE

View

4

POLITICAL PARTIES

View

5

OUTCOMES OF DEMOCRACY

View

1

THE RISE OF NATIONALISM IN EUROPE

View

2

NATIONALISM IN INDIA

View

3

THE MAKING OF A GLOBAL WORLD

View

4

THE AGE OF INDUSTRIALISATION

View

5

PRINT CULTURE AND THE MODERN WORLD

View

1

DEVELOPMENT

View

2

SECTORS OF THE INDIAN ECONOMY

View

3

MONEY AND CREDIT

View

4

GLOBALISATION AND THE INDIAN ECONOMY

View

5

CONSUMER RIGHTS

View